Commentary - Archives of Dentistry (2021) Volume 3, Issue 1
Respiratory Protection - Even in the Bigger Picture, it is Often the Smallest Details that Take Your Breath Away
Ram Prakash1*, Uday Kumar Digumarthi2
1Department of Prosthodontics, Anil Neerukonda Institute of Dental Sciences, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, India
2Department of Orthodontics, Anil Neerukonda Institute of Dental Sciences, Visakhapatnam, India
- *Corresponding Author:
- Ram Prakash
Received date: November 05, 2020; Accepted date: December 30, 2020
Citation: Prakash R, Digumarthi UK. Respiratory Protection - Even in the Bigger Picture, it is Often the Smallest Details that Take
Your Breath Away. Arch Dent. 2021; 3(1):8-10.
Copyright: © 2021 Prakash R, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
It is surprising and even endearing in a way that we, as humans, live life looking ahead with hope, always believing in a better tomorrow, sometimes being oblivious to risks and dangers, often telling ourselves that bad things probably only happen to others and that the threats mentioned are in reality not as bad as they seem . As health care workers, although fear is supposed to be one of the greatest motivators, we bring a bit of this nonchalant attitude to our workplaces in being slightly indifferent especially to the dangers we know but can’t see and thus do not fear, in what is often referred to as the ‘health belief’ model [2-4].
Much like how it took the AIDS pandemic to bring about a need to wear gloves as a universal precaution, it has taken a series of respiratory pandemics to highlight the need for respiratory protection [5-8]. But then again in spite of Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (earlier the Communicable Disease Center or CDC) advisories in 1996 that were updated stressing on the need for gloves as part of the standard precautions and the fact that patients were more comfortable with doctors treating them with gloves on, there has surprisingly been much debate over the need and efficacy of gloves citing problems like doubtful efficiency in view of micro pores, allergy to materials like latex or even decreased manual dexterity and tactile perception [9-21]. A study also concluded that training in itself by way of infection control education need not positively enforce compliance .
One of the most neglected aspects of healthcare workers’ health has been that of respiratory health [23-26]. Two reasons for this are a lack of implementation of a stress on respiratory protection in educational settings coupled with a lack of a disciplined approach towards the same including a dedicated donning and doffing protocol [27,28]. If one takes just a moment to check the plethora
of variants of respiratory protection available as per the
Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
regulations for general, construction and maritime
industries or the guidelines laid down in the National
Institute for Occupational Safety & Health (NIOSH) guide
to industrial respiratory protection of 1987, one might
actually be truly concerned as to why we never considered
ourselves worthy enough of similar protection . The
first attempt at introducing respirators into the healthcare
arena was probably with the release of the NIOSH TB
Respiratory Protection Program in Health Care Facilities,
administrative guide in 1999 . This was assumed to
be a mandatory guideline in areas where there would be
definite exposure to patients infected with tuberculosis.
The discomfort associated with wearing even a simple
three-ply surgical mask and the need to feel presentable
or even clearly audible while discussing aspects of the
treatment plan or expenses with a patient has more often
than not prompted the removal of respiratory protection
thus defeating any attempt at thoroughly complying
with respiratory protection guidelines [1-34]. Most often
a mask is removed by a healthcare worker soon after a
procedure is complete oblivious to the suspended aerosol
that still lingers, suspended, in the very same room for
almost half an hour unless engineering controls exist to
evacuate contaminated air from the room . There have
been infection control advisories released by regulatory
or advisory bodies, as with the CDC advisories that were
updated after the 2009 H1N1 pandemic, that have tried
laying down standard protocols including methods of
controlling or minimizing aerosol and most of these
originate from the universal precautions safeguarding
against blood borne infections with the inclusion of
protection against exposure to other body fluids or any other potentially infective material [12,13,36,37].
The stress, however, on respiratory protection has been very cursory especially in its acceptance or compliance. If there had been emphatic insistence much like that for an industrial worker you would have filtration protection of probably the highest filtration efficiency becoming the standard norm for healthcare institutions even prior to the H1N1 Pandemic. Having used a surgeon’s mask for more than 100 years there was limited acceptance of the tighter fitting N95 type respirators [32,33]. Enter a pandemic like Covid-19 and the sudden realization hits that what we need now is probably the very same respiratory protection we should have been using all along but now there’s a short supply. The next realization is that as we don’t seem to use respiratory protection that much which is why we do not have enough supplies backed up and we desperately search for others who might be using similar protection. We turn to the supplies that in actual reality were meant for the common industrial man working with wood, stone, steel or chemicals. In a bid to save lives we need every single non-medical particulate respirator that is available because their filtration efficiency is the exact same standard of the medical equivalent with just a small difference that the surface is not as splash resistant. In Asian countries wearing a mask has always been a social norm . We have seen a shift in advisories for the general public ranging from no need for a mask to the current suggestion that at least some form of facial covering is desirable. Now we see a shift in global preferences for respiratory protection as our perceptions have been forced to change radically as the truth slowly dawns upon us all.
Let us, for a moment, forget about Covid-19, the opportunistic airborne infection. We have around us obligate airborne infections like tuberculosis too. Apart from the risk of contracting respiratory diseases in settings outside a health care facility shouldn’t there have been mandatory respiratory protection protocol enforced in all healthcare setups all along making us better prepared to handle the current pandemic instead of allowing it to just …take our breath away!
- Diethelm P, McKee M. Denialism: what is it and how
should scientists respond?. The European Journal of
Public Health. 2009 Jan 1;19(1):2-4.
- Platace D, Millere I. Motivating factors of infection
control in nurse practice. InSHS Web of Conferences 2018
(Vol. 51, p. 02010). EDP Sciences.
- Glanz K, Rimer BK, Viswanath K, editors. Health
behavior and health education: theory, research, and
practice. John Wiley & Sons; 2008 Aug 28.
- Rosenstock IM, Strecher VJ, Becker MH. Social
learning theory and the health belief model. Health
Education Quarterly. 1988 Jun;15(2):175-83.
- Loeb M, McGeer A, Henry B, Ofner M, Rose D, Hlywka
T, et al. SARS among critical care nurses, Toronto.
Emerging infectious diseases. 2004 Feb;10(2):251-55.
- Chen WK, Wu HD, Lin CC, Cheng YC. Emergency
department response to SARS, Taiwan. Emerging
Infectious Diseases. 2005 Jul;11(7):1067-73.
- Mitchell R, Ogunremi T, Astrakianakis G, Bryce E,
Gervais R, Gravel D, et al. Impact of the 2009 influenza
A (H1N1) pandemic on Canadian health care workers: a
survey on vaccination, illness, absenteeism, and personal
protective equipment. American Journal of Infection
Control. 2012 Sep 1;40(7):611-6.
- Chughtai AA, Seale H, Dung TC, Maher L, Nga PT,
MacIntyre CR. Current practices and barriers to the use
of facemasks and respirators among hospital-based health
care workers in Vietnam. American Journal of Infection
Control. 2015 Jan 1;43(1):72-7.
- Yoder KS. Patients’ attitudes toward the routine use of
surgical gloves in a dental office. Journal (Indiana Dental
- Editorial: Practitioners surveyed report dramatic
increase in glove usage. Dental Products Report. 1987;12:1.
- OSHA joint advisory notice: Protection against
occupational exposure to HBV and HIV. October 19, 1987.
- Centers for Disease Control (CDC. Update:
acquired immunodeficiency syndrome and human
immunodeficiency virus infection among health-care
workers. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. 1988
- CDC A. Guidelines for prevention of transmission of human immunodeficiency virus and hepatitis B virus to health-care and public-safety workers. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report June 23. 1989 Jun 23;38:1-37.
- Most dentists wear gloves, survey says. American
Dental Association News. 1989;20(3):1-2, 4.
- Solovan DF, Uldricks JM, Caccamo P, Beck FM.
Evaluation of oral procedures performed with gloves: a
pilot study. Dental Hygiene. 1984 Mar;58(3):122-4.
- Reingold AL, Kane MA, Hightower AW. Failure of
gloves and other protective devices to prevent transmission
of hepatitis B virus to oral surgeons. JAMA. 1988 May
- Neiburger EJ. Gloves and manual dexterity. Journal
of the American Association Forensic Dentists. 1990;13:1-4.
- Arnold SG, Whitman JE, FOX CH, COTTLER-FOX
MH. Latex gloves not enough to exclude viruses. Nature.
1988 Sep 1;335(6185):19-.
- Brough SJ, Hunt TM, Barrie WW. Surgical
glove perforations. British Journal of Surgery. 1988
- Gonzalez E, Naleway C. Assessment of the effectiveness
of glove use as a barrier technique in the dental operatory.
The Journal of the American Dental Association. 1988 Sep
- Christensen GJ. Operating gloves: The good and the
bad. The Journal of the American Dental Association.
2001 Oct 1;132(10):1455-7.
- Ward DJ. The role of education in the prevention
and control of infection: a review of the literature. Nurse
Education Today. 2011 Jan 1;31(1):9-17.
- Cohen HJ, Birkner JS. Respiratory protection. Clinics
in Chest Medicine. 2012 Dec 1;33(4):783-93.
- Ruderman C, Tracy CS, Bensimon CM, Bernstein M,
Hawryluck L, Shaul RZ, Upshur RE. On pandemics and
the duty to care: whose duty? who cares?. BMC Medical
Ethics. 2006 Dec;7(1):1-6.
- Bessesen M, Price CS, Simberkoff M, Reich N, Pavia
A, Radonovich L. N95 Respirators or Surgical Masks to
Protect Healthcare Workers against Respiratory Infections:
Are We There Yet?. American Journal of Respiratory and
Critical Care Medicine. 2013;187(9):904-905.
- Peterson K, Novak D, Stradtman L, Wilson D, Couzens
L. Hospital respiratory protection practices in 6 US states:
a public health evaluation study. American Journal of
Infection Control. 2015 Jan 1;43(1):63-71.
- Coia JE, Ritchie L, Adisesh A, Booth CM, Bradley C,
Bunyan D, et al. Guidance on the use of respiratory and
facial protection equipment. Journal of Hospital Infection.
2013 Nov 1;85(3):170-82.
- Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies
Rapid Response Reports. Canadian Agency for Drugs
and Technologies in Health; Ottawa ON: 2014. Wear
compliance and donning/doffing of respiratory protection
for bioaerosols or infectious agents: a review of the
effectiveness, safety, and guidelines.
- Bollinger NJ, Schutz RH. NIOSH guide to industrial
respiratory protection. DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 87-116, 1987: 3-79
- TB Respiratory Protection Program in Health Care
Facilities, administrative guide. Ohio: NIOSH ; 1999
- Nichol K, McGeer A, Bigelow P, O’Brien-Pallas L, Scott
J, Holness DL. Behind the mask: Determinants of nurse’s
adherence to facial protective equipment. American
Journal of Infection Control. 2013 Jan 1;41(1):8-13.
- Locatelli SM, LaVela SL, Gosch M. Health care
workers’ reported discomfort while wearing filtering
face-piece respirators. Workplace Health & Safety. 2014
- Radonovich LJ, Cheng J, Shenal BV, Hodgson M,
Bender BS. Respirator tolerance in health care workers.
Jama. 2009 Jan 7;301(1):36-8.
- Sim SW, Moey KS, Tan NC. The use of facemasks to
prevent respiratory infection: a literature review in the
context of the Health Belief Model. Singapore Medical
Journal. 2014; 55:160–167.
- Hinds WC. Aerosol technology: properties, behavior,
and measurement of airborne particles. John Wiley &
Sons; 1999 Jan 19:182-204.
- Infection control recommendations for the dental
office and the dental laboratory, Infection control
recommendations for the dental office and the dental
laboratory. ADA Council on Scientific Affairs and ADA
Council on Dental Practice. Journal of the American
Dental Association. 1996; 127:672-80.
- Harrel SK, Barnes JB, Rivera-Hidalgo F. Aerosol
reduction during air polishing. Quintessence International.
1999 Sep 1;30(9).
- Burgess A, Horii M. Risk, ritual and health
responsibilisation: Japan’s ‘safety blanket’of surgical
face mask-wearing. Sociology of Health & Illness. 2012