Healthy Fetal Outcomes using a Novel Treatment for Maternal Lyme Disease and Babesiosis During Consecutive Pregnancies: A Case Study and Literature Review

Babesia is a single celled protozoan parasite which may be transmitted through the bite of an infected tick, blood transfusion and/ or maternal-fetal transmission. We describe the case of a woman previously treated for Lyme disease and babesiosis who relapsed with severe malaria-like symptoms during the 3rd trimester of two consecutive pregnancies. Testing for active babesiosis was positive in both pregnancies despite prior conventional therapies, and she was subsequently treated with high dose atovaquone (1500 mg PO BID) and Zithromax during each of her 3rd trimesters, along with clindamycin during her 3rd pregnancy. At term, neonates were healthy with no clinical evidence of active babesiosis (no fever, acute respiratory distress syndrome [ARDS], hepatosplenomegaly or jaundice) and no laboratory evidence of babesiosis (no positive blood smears, hemolytic anemia, neutropenia or thrombocytopenia). Intramuscular benzathine penicillin was simultaneously used throughout her four pregnancies to prevent transmission of Borrelia burgdorferi, the agent of Lyme disease, with no evidence of transmission of the spirochete to the fetuses. Although this novel Lyme and Babesia therapy was effective in preventing congenital transmission of Borrelia burgdorferi and Babesia microti in consecutive pregnancies, future studies are needed to define the optimal management strategy for pregnant patients with Lyme disease and babesiosis due to the possible relapsing, remitting nature of the disease and the potential for associated morbidity and mortality. Horowitz R, Freeman PR. Healthy Fetal Outcomes using a Novel Treatment for Maternal Lyme Disease and Babesiosis During Consecutive Pregnancies: A Case Study and Literature Review. Arch Med Case Rep. 2020; 2(1): 1-19. Arch Med Case Rep. 2020 Volume 2, Issue 1 2 [21], and atovaquone and azithromycin [22], both established regimens for the treatment of babesiosis [23]. She was subsequently rotated to a combination regimen of higher dose atovaquone (1500 mg PO BID) and azithromycin, along with a 10-day course of clindamycin during her third pregnancy. At birth, all neonates were asymptomatic with healthy Apgar scores and no clinical or laboratory signs of active babesiosis. Published medical literature on treatment for babesiosis during pregnancy recommends either clindamycin and quinine [24], or atovaquone and azithromycin [25], with variable outcomes in neonates, oftentimes resulting in thrombocytopenia and hemolytic anemia requiring a blood transfusion [17]. It is therefore imperative to find novel therapies that are safe and effective. Our case report is to our knowledge the first to describe the use of a novel combination of Lyme disease and babesiosis therapies during pregnancy which were well tolerated and beneficial in the mother, without clinical or laboratory signs of active infections of B. burgdorferi or B. microti in the newborns.

We present the case of a woman with a well-documented history of infection with B. burgdorferi, the agent of Lyme disease, who was co-infected with B. microti before and during her pregnancy. Despite traditional antibiotic and antimalarial therapy for Lyme disease and babesiosis she remained ill. At the beginning of her third trimester, and during two consecutive pregnancies, she complained both times of the sudden onset of drenching sweats, flushing, and chills along with worsening fatigue and headaches. Retesting for babesia showed evidence of an active infection in both pregnancies despite prior treatments with clindamycin Arch Med Case Rep. 2020 Volume 2, Issue 1 2 [21], and atovaquone and azithromycin [22], both established regimens for the treatment of babesiosis [23]. She was subsequently rotated to a combination regimen of higher dose atovaquone (1500 mg PO BID) and azithromycin, along with a 10-day course of clindamycin during her third pregnancy. At birth, all neonates were asymptomatic with healthy Apgar scores and no clinical or laboratory signs of active babesiosis. Published medical literature on treatment for babesiosis during pregnancy recommends either clindamycin and quinine [24], or atovaquone and azithromycin [25], with variable outcomes in neonates, oftentimes resulting in thrombocytopenia and hemolytic anemia requiring a blood transfusion [17]. It is therefore imperative to find novel therapies that are safe and effective. Our case report is to our knowledge the first to describe the use of a novel combination of Lyme disease and babesiosis therapies during pregnancy which were well tolerated and beneficial in the mother, without clinical or laboratory signs of active infections of B. burgdorferi or B. microti in the newborns.

Case History
A 27-year-old white female with a past medical history significant for Lyme disease, babesiosis, Helicobacter pylori, hypothyroidism, neurocardiogenic syncope, celiac disease, food allergies, migraines, irritable bowel syndrome and multiple chemical sensitivity came to see us with the chief complaints of symptomatic fatigue, headaches, and multiple joint pains. She had a history of chronic joint pain for several years of unknown etiology, followed by getting a tick bite and erythema migrans rash while living in Europe. Her ELISA and IgM Western blot became CDC positive after her tick bite (positive 23 KDA [OspC], 39 KDA, 41 KDA), along with a positive B.microti IgM titer (1:160+), and despite prompt treatment she remained ill and symptomatic for years. She then moved to the West Coast of the United States and underwent treatment with rotations of antibiotics for a chronic relapsing H. pylori infection, which included several courses of amoxicillin, metronidazole, and clarithromycin. Her G.I. symptoms eventually improved. She subsequently received treatment for her Lyme disease and babesiosis, which included rotations of antibiotics including doxycycline + mefloquine; atovaquone + telithromycin; as well as metronidazole + clarithromycin. Despite these antibiotic rotations, there was no clinical improvement in her resistant fatigue, headaches or joint pain.
The patient and her family then moved to the East Coast of the United States and came to our medical center for a diagnostic evaluation. At the time of her initial visit, her chief complaints included: daily day and night sweats which were drenching; constant hot flashes and chills; chronic fatigue; sore throat; hair loss; the sensation of "air hunger" and shortness of breath, both at rest and exertion; chest pain with tenderness to palpation of the chest wall; palpitations, which improved with the use of metoprolol; migratory joint pain which was worse in her shoulders, neck, ankles, knees, and bilateral great toes; soreness of the soles of her feet; myalgias in her upper and lower extremities; constant tingling and numbness of her fingers and toes, which increased with the use of atovaquone and clarithromycin, but not metronidazole; occasional paresthesias of the face; blurry vision and photosensitivity; sound sensitivity and increased sensitivity to smells; dizziness with episodes of vertigo; tinnitus; hearing loss (prior to antibiotic use); memory and concentration problems with word finding problems and emotional instability. She felt that she was functioning at 30 to 40 percent of her normal level due to the severity of these symptoms.
Social history and family history were unremarkable. One brother was alive and well with a history of syncopal episodes. She grew up around cats as pets. Allergies included dermatological reactions to nickel (rash) and intolerance to azithromycin and metronidazole (nausea), mefloquine (nausea, weakness, visual hallucinations), and cortisone injections (anaphylactic shock). Medications at the time of her initial visit included clarithromycin 500 milligrams PO BID and metronidazole 500 milligrams BID along with metoprolol 25 milligrams QD; Armour Thyroid 15 milligrams QD; a baby aspirin, meloxicam 15 milligrams QD for pain and a birth control pill (microgestin 1/20 QD).
Review of systems was negative except for previously described symptoms as well as occasional edema of the lower extremities; intermittent dysphagia, gas and stomach pain; rare yeast infections with urinary frequency; muscle weakness; eczema; anxiety and multiple syncopal episodes.
Physical examination revealed a well-developed, wellnourished white female in no apparent distress. She was afebrile. Her blood pressure was 118/74 with a pulse of 74 beats per minute (regular), and respiratory rate of 16 per minute. Physical exam was unremarkable except for cool, mottled extremities consistent with probable dysautonomia; dry skin of her hands with a bilateral erythematous, violaceous rash, consistent with acrodermatitis chronicum atrophicans. (Figure 1) and reddish streaks and striae on various parts of her body which were perpendicular to skin planes ( Figure  2), suggestive of possible bartonellosis. Blood tests revealed a normal complete blood count (CBC), comprehensive metabolic profile (CMP), thyroid functions, Dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) sulfate level, growth hormone (GH) level (normal insulin like growth factor 1 [IGF-1], which varied over time), B12, methylmalonic acid (MMA), homocysteine and folic acid levels, immunoglobulin levels and subclasses, mineral levels (copper, zinc, magnesium, iron), C-reactive protein (CRP), sedimentation rates, creatinine phosphokinase (CPK) and rheumatoid factors, anti-myelin associated glycoproteins (anti-MAG antibodies), along with a normal IgE level and IgE food allergy panel. IgG 4 food antibody levels however were positive for mild allergies to rye, peanuts, almonds, sesame, sunflower, avocado, garlic, mustard and green peppers with moderate reactions to wheat, soy, and eggs. These results were consistent with the diagnosis of leaky gut. Over time, Epstein-Barr virus and herpesvirus 6 titers became low positive, but without a fourfold increase in titers.
Review of prior outpatient testing revealed a possible episode of ventricular tachycardia while having an IV placed for a tilt table test, to rule out Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome (POTS) so she was sent for a cardiology evaluation and cardiac stress test, which showed normal myocardial perfusion and no significant cardiac abnormalities. A 24-hour Holter monitor  revealed extra beats without significant arrhythmias. She did intermittently have evidence of hypotension, dropping her blood pressure from 100/64 to 85/55 with a 14 point increase in heart rate and lightheadedness, consistent with the diagnosis of moderate POTS. A brain SPECT scan showed severe hypoperfusion. A fivehour glucose tolerance test was also performed for the history of fatigue, lightheadedness, palpitations and syncope with the history of a low glucose level one time, which revealed a hypoglycemic response during the 4th hour when the blood sugar dropped to 53 milligrams/ deciliter (normal range 65-99 mg/dl) and the patient became symptomatic. She was subsequently placed on a low carbohydrate diet with small frequent meals and adequate levels of protein, which helped stabilize postprandial fatigue. Her endocrinologist also placed her on a small dose of hydrocortisone (Cortef, 5 mg/day) for her low adrenal function, with mild improvement in fatigue and stamina.
Since the patient had never used a cell wall antibiotic (penicillins, cephalosporins) for Lyme disease and complained of significant neurocognitive symptoms, she was placed on IV ceftriaxone (Rocephin) 2 grams per day, ursodiol (Actigall) 300 milligrams PO BID, atovaquone (Mepron) 750 milligrams, 2 teaspoons PO BID with a high-fat meal, clarithromycin XL 500 milligrams BID, hydroxychloroquine (Plaquenil) 200 milligrams PO BID and nystatin 500,000 units tablets, 2 PO BID. Despite this protocol, she complained of daily drenching sweats, severe fatigue, increased joint and muscle pain, headaches, and worsening cognitive impairment. Bactrim double strength (sulfamethoxazole/trimethoprim) one PO BID was therefore added to the regimen, along with extra detoxification support, including IV glutathione 3 days per week. She reported improvements days that she was on IV glutathione and her sweats and chills became less frequent with the addition of Bactrim to the regimen. Herxheimer reactions however continued the days on IV ceftriaxone, despite trying to pulse the IV medication 4 days in a row per week, so she was subsequently taken off this protocol, and switched to IV doxycycline 200 milligrams per day, infused over a 2 hour time period along with Plaquenil, nystatin, and rifampin 300 milligrams PO BID. Day and night sweats, chills, and peripheral neuropathy symptoms increased off her atovaquone and Rocephin, so she was rotated to clindamycin 300 milligrams, 2 capsules 3 × per day, atovaquone 2 teaspoons PO BID along with clarithromycin 500 milligrams BID for her babesiosis. High dose B12 injections were also started for the resistant neuropathy along with alpha lipoic acid 600 milligrams QD with B6 50 milligrams TID.
After one month, the only improvement she experienced was a decrease in sweats for one to two days, which subsequently increased in intensity with severe fatigue, severe cognitive dysfunction, headaches, leg pain, myalgias and peripheral neuropathy. She was therefore rotated to doxycycline, ciprofloxacin 500 milligrams PO BID and atovaquone/proguanil to 50/100 milligrams, 4 tablets per day, with low dose mefloquine (250 milligrams Q5 days) for the possibility of resistant bartonellosis along with Lyme disease and babesiosis, but unfortunately this regimen was ineffective in significantly relieving symptomatology, so all antibiotics were stopped, and the patient was placed on a yeast-free, sugar-free diet with an herbal protocol for her tickborne diseases. Herbals included Samento (cat's claw), Cumunda, Enula, Burbur, and parsley. Within days of being off her antibiotics, all symptoms worsened including severe depression where she was crying for hours at a time, so she was placed back on a Babesia protocol, including atovaquone, clarithromycin and Bactrim DS twice a day. This immediately helped resolve the mood swings and decreased associated fevers, sweats, chills, and palpitations.
At the end of 2008, after several months on this protocol, the patient decided to try getting pregnant. Options were discussed for her pregnancy including oral penicillin's, cephalosporins or intramuscular benzathine penicillin (IM Bicillin) with azithromycin which have all been shown to be safe for the fetus [26]. She chose intramuscular Bicillin 1.2 million units IM twice a week with EMLA cream one hour prior to the injection. She was to stay on atovaquone, clarithromycin and Bactrim, which were controlling her Babesia symptoms until she got pregnant. Over the next few months, the Bicillin injections helped her to feel better with improvement in energy and cognitive functioning, and eventually the Bactrim was stopped. One month later, the patient became pregnant and tapered off clarithromycin and nystatin but stayed on low-dose hydrocortisone (2.5 milligram BID) and Armour thyroid (dosage of 90 mg/day) as per her endocrinologist, along with Bicillin and azithromycin (Zithromax). She followed the pregnancy with a highrisk OB/GYN at Yale who placed her on a prenatal multivitamin with folic acid and extra vitamin D (7000 IU/d) for subtherapeutic vitamin D levels, and her Armour thyroid was increased to 120 mg/day in the third trimester for borderline elevated levels of TSH (3.04 microIU/ml, optimum range below 2.5 microIU/ml). IgF1 levels were intermittently low (121 ng/ml, normal range 138-410 ng/ml), suggestive of growth hormone (GH) deficiency, but due to normal fetal growth, levels were followed. A beta blocker, labetalol, proven to be safe in pregnancy [27], was also prescribed at 100 mg PO BID and was effective in controlling palpitations. She carried the fetus to term and gave birth to a healthy baby girl by vaginal delivery, with no signs or symptoms of active Lyme or babesiosis. Real time Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing of the placenta and cord blood was negative for B. burgdorferi or B. microti. The patient began breast feeding, and breast milk was also checked for any evidence of B. burgdorferi, which was negative. A subsequent IgF1 level became normal (147, normal range 114-492) and a glucagon stimulation test indicated normal GH production (13.2 ng/ml, peak GH of 3 ng/ml or higher being normal). 25-OH Vitamin D levels also became normal (60 ng/ml, range 20-100 ng/ ml) over time but 1,25 OH Vit D levels were elevated at 153 pg/ml (normal range 19-67 pg/ml). Vitamin D dosing was decreased accordingly.
Shortly after giving birth and during the period of breast feeding for approximately one year, the patient noticed increased symptoms of resistant fatigue and sweats. She had remained on Bicillin injections during this time, which were increased post-partum to 2.4 million units twice a week (total of 4.8 million units) for resistant fatigue, which improved with the higher dose of intramuscular penicillin. Bactrim DS was added to Zithromax along with higher dose atovaquone (3 tsp PO BID) for resistant Babesia symptoms, which also improved symptomatology. Her perceived level of functioning increased from 30% to 65% of normal during that time, a significant improvement from prior baseline levels of functioning.
Approximately one year into breast feeding (10/2010) the patient became pregnant for the second time and all medications were stopped except for Bicillin injections and Armour thyroid. She was able to taper off low dose hydrocortisone without difficulty, since subsequent cortisol measurements were within normal limits. Labetalol, an alpha and beta blocker, was also stopped because of urinary urge incontinence which developed post-partum, which improved off the medication. The patient remained at 70% normal functioning during the second pregnancy without any yeast or diarrhea (she was continuously on three probiotics twice a day with Saccharomyces boulardii during the course of treatment) [28]. Resistant joint pain bilaterally in the wrists, knees and shoulders persisted, as did fatigue, dizziness, headaches, light and sound sensitivity and memory/concentration problems, which varied between mild to severe in intensity. Although palpitations were initially controlled off Labetalol, the medication needed to be re-added at half dose (50 mg BID) once extrasystoles returned later in the pregnancy. The labetalol was better tolerated at lower dosing without any associated incontinence, and no orthostatic intolerance was seen with the addition of the low dose beta blocker.
At term on 7/2011, the patient gave birth vaginally to a healthy baby boy. Again, B. burgdorferi Real-Time PCR of the placenta and B. burgdorferi Real-Time PCR and B. microti Real-Time PCR of the cord blood were negative without signs or symptoms of active babesiosis in the neonate. The patient also denied significant day or night sweats or air hunger during her second pregnancy or several months into the post-partum period (symptoms of active babesiosis), although these symptoms relapsed by 1/2012 when day sweats and night sweats returned several times a week. She felt that Bicillin injections remained her best Lyme disease treatment to date, despite resistant symptoms of fatigue, joint pain, and headaches as these symptoms often improved immediately post injection. Zithromax and rifampin were added post-partum (rifampin may be used while pregnant and breastfeeding, as there is no known risk of infant harm) [29], and the patient felt an improvement in her moods, fatigue and headaches with the addition of the 2nd intracellular medication. Dosing of rifampin higher than 150 milligrams PO BID caused significant Herxheimer reactions however, suggestive of an active intracellular infection, and any attempt to lower the Bicillin injections to 1.2 million units twice a week resulted in an increase in headaches and mood swings.
The patient remained stable on this regimen until 10/2012 when she had a syncopal episode post venipuncture. It was subsequently determined that she was pregnant for the third time. An ultrasound at 16 weeks was normal and she was again followed by her high-risk OB-GYN.
At the end of her second trimester her night sweats began to return with increased fatigue and headaches. Repeat testing for tick-borne diseases was performed and revealed an ongoing positive B.microti IgM antibody at 1:160 + (IgeneX laboratories), new positive Babesia duncani (WA-1) IgG immunofluorescent antibody at 1:256 + (Bioreference laboratory, normal reference range below 1:256). Testing for Coxiella burnetti (Q-fever), Brucella, Rickettsia rickettsii (Rocky mountain spotted fever), Bartonella henselae, and toxoplasma gondii were all negative. ANA, rheumatoid factor and sedimentation rates along with thyroid functions were also within normal limits. No other explanation for the sweats could be found, so a confirmatory blood test was sent to Mayo Clinic which showed a low positive IgM B. microti at 1:40+ with a negative PCR. A blood smear was sent to visualize parasites, but the specimen was deemed too old to be useful. A repeat Babesia FISH test was therefore sent to IgeneX laboratories as it provides a significant increase in sensitivity and specificity over standard Giemsa Laboratory blood tests during that time intermittently showed toxic vacuolation and granulations present in the white cells with myelocytes present, a mild anemia with a hemoglobin of 11.5 g/dl (normal range 12-16 g/dL), hemoglobin of 34.9 (normal range 36-46%), slightly low platelet counts ranging between 116,000/ UL and 130,000/UL (normal range 140-400,000/ UL) with normal liver and kidney functions. She was placed back on clindamycin 300 mg 2 PO BID for 10 days along with atovaquone 750 mg, two tsp PO BID with a high fat meal and azithromycin 250 mg PO BID throughout the third trimester. After one week on atovaquone the sweats significantly decreased and she felt an improvement in her overall symptomatology, although muscle and joint pains and neuropathy continued to be moderate to severe in intensity. She remained on Bicillin injections during this time and a long acting oral amoxicillin (Moxatag 775 mg) was added during the 3rd trimester as higher dose Bicillin injections helped decrease symptomatology in the past. This resulted in improvement in headaches and fatigue.
Her high-risk OB/GYN and neonatal infectious disease specialist were consulted, who agreed with the plan, and the patient gave birth to her 3rd child, a healthy girl, in the summer of 2013. Apgar scores were normal. Testing of the cord blood for B. burgdorferi During 2014, the patient continued to breastfeed and clinically improved as long as she stayed on Bicillin injections, atovaquone, azithromycin, and Bactrim DS with a low carbohydrate, Paleo diet which also helped stabilize her energy and headaches. By August 2014, she was functioning at 85% of normal functioning, a significant improvement from her baseline. However, each time she tried to lower the dose of Bicillin injections or Moxatag/probenecid for her Lyme disease, or discontinue atovaquone and Bactrim for Babesia, her fatigue, headaches, migratory joint pain and sweats significantly increased. A high salt diet and fluids helped decrease orthostatic changes.
The patient decided to try for her 4th child in the fall of 2014 after breastfeeding for 17 months and became pregnant by the end of December 2014. Cefixime (Suprax) 400 mg QD was added during the first trimester due to significant joint pain, which helped decrease the intensity. During her visit of 6/2015, at the end of her second trimester, all prenatal checkups were fine and higher dose Bicillin and cefixime were helping to decrease her joint pain. Although she complained of resistant fatigue and dizziness, there were no orthostatic changes or increases in heart rate during her physical examination, ruling out significant dysautonomia as a potential etiology.
The patient initially denied significant fever, sweats or chills, but did complain of ongoing "air hunger" and a cough, atypical symptoms of babesiosis. Based on these symptoms and her prior history of relapses with proof of active infection, repeat Babesia titers and a FISH test were performed, as well as repeat titers for other tickborne infections. Almost immediately upon returning to her home in the southeastern United States, and beginning her 3rd trimester, her sweats began to return, occasionally drenching in nature. Although she denied any new tick bites, her B. microti IgM titer had now increased to 1:320+, her IgG B.microti titer turned positive at 1:40+ while her Babesia FISH test remained positive. Repeat Western blots for Lyme disease revealed an increase in the 31 KDA band (outer surface protein A) and decrease of her 23 KDA band (outer surface protein C) on her IgM blot from baseline measurements.
The patient therefore was placed back on high dose Mepron (atovaquone) 2 teaspoons PO BID with azithromycin during her 3rd trimester for active relapsing babesiosis. Clindamycin, which had been added during her 3rd pregnancy, was held due to ongoing nausea. Symptoms significantly improved once high dose atovaquone was re-added to the protocol, with a significant decrease in both the frequency and intensity of headaches and decrease in sweats (which Arch Med Case Rep. 2020 Volume 2, Issue 1 were primarily at night, 2 to 3 times per week).
She gave birth at term by vaginal delivery to a healthy boy in the fall of 2015, with normal Apgar scores and no signs or symptoms of babesiosis (lack of anemia, thrombocytopenia, transaminitis, hepatosplenomegaly or jaundice). Repeat real-time PCR's of the cord blood for B. burgdorferi, B. microti, B. henselae, B. quintana, and qualitative PCRs for Mycoplasma species from MDL laboratories were all negative. Clindamycin and Bactrim needed to be added several months into breastfeeding however (the pediatrician concurred) when drenching night sweats returned. Despite a temporary increase in emotional lability with Bactrim, symptoms subsequently resolved.
Follow-up titers for babesiosis months later showed a further increase in B. microti IgM titers to 1:640+ (a fourfold increase from her initial titers) with the IgG B. microti titer turning negative, yet the patient remained stable on her regimen and baby continued to do well. To date, years later, all four children have remained healthy. This case report is to our knowledge the first one to describe the safe and effective use of high dose benzathine penicillin injections along with high dose atovaquone, azithromycin and clindamycin to prevent the perinatal transmission of Lyme disease and babesiosis in multiple consecutive pregnancies.
Tick bites within 3 years preceding conception have been shown to be significantly associated with congenital malformations [51] and our patient had a history of chronic joint pain for several years after getting a tick bite and erythema migrans rash while living in Europe. She also had a bilateral erythematous, violaceous rash on her hands, consistent with acrodermatitis chronicum atrophicans (Figure 1). This is a chronic dermatological manifestation seen more often in women and associated with Borrelia afzelii in Europe [52]. In North America, although Lyme disease is primarily caused by B. burgdorferi sensu stricto and/or eight other sensu lato species (B. mayonii, B. americana, B. andersonii, B.  bissettii, B. californiensis, B. carolinensis, B. garinii,  and B. kurtenbachii) [53][54][55][56][57][58], in Europe the majority of cases of Lyme borreliosis are caused by Borrelia afzelii and Borrelia garinii leading to a broad range of clinical manifestations [59]. As our patient had a history of both classic dermatological skin lesions seen in Lyme disease, an EM rash and ACA, several borrelia species may have been involved in the chronicity of her illness.
Successes and failures of treating ACA and EM rashes with traditional antibiotics have been reported. In one study of ACA, B. burgdorferi DNA excretion was still positive after 12 months [60], and atypical forms of B. burgdorferi were visualized under the microscope with positive staining for borrelia genusspecific monoclonal flagellar antibody [61]. These may have represented in vivo morphologic variants of this bacterium [61], which have been shown to form round body forms [62,63], stationary phase cells and persister cells [64][65][66], as well as aggregates in biofilms [67][68][69], depending on environmental conditions and stressors [65,70]. Successful cultivation of spirochetes from skin lesions of patients with erythema migrans (EM) and Acrodermatitis chronica atrophicans with a disease duration of greater than 10 years also suggests that the spirochetes may survive in the human body for a considerable time [71]. This was confirmed in a study of recurrent erythema migrans despite extended antibiotic treatment [72]. In that study, persistent B. burgdorferi infection was found in the blood by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) while skin biopsy specimen contained Borrelia-compatible structures [72]. These findings are consistent with other published scientific literature showing persistence of B. burgdorferi despite seemingly adequate courses of antibiotics [73,74], where the bacteria can persist in various parts of the body where antibiotics may not easily penetrate. These include the ligamentous tissue [75], intracellular compartment and synovium [76,77], joints [78], joint fluid [79], spleen [80], eyes [81,82], neuronal and glial cells [83], endothelial cells and macrophages [84], and central nervous system [85]. Persistence in skin lesions in EM and ACA may be due to immune evasion [86], biofilms protecting the organism [68,87], as well as invasion of human skin fibroblasts by B. burgdorferi [88], where fibroblasts can protect the Lyme disease spirochete from the effect of antibiotics, including ceftriaxone [89], which the patient received early on in the course of her treatment.
A 2018 systematic review on the impact of gestational Lyme disease in humans on the fetus and newborn reported significantly fewer adverse birth outcomes in women reported to have been treated for gestational Arch Med Case Rep. 2020 Volume 2, Issue 1 Lyme disease (LD) (11%, 95% confidence interval [CI]) compared to those who were not treated during pregnancy (50%, 95% CI) providing indirect evidence of an association between gestational LD and adverse birth outcomes [90]. Among those fetal abnormalities noted, adverse outcomes with a possible association included syndactyly, cortical blindness, hydrocephalus, intrauterine fetal death [38], prematurity, rash in the newborn [91], as well as stillbirth [92] neonatal distress syndrome, intrauterine growth retardation, maternal toxemia of pregnancy and sudden infant death syndrome [38].
Despite these findings, prior reviews of the literature concerning the effects of gestational LD from case reports and series, epidemiologic studies, and experimental animal models have yielded conflicting results [93,94] and inconsistent evidence for adverse birth outcomes of gestational LD in the epidemiological research [90]. Also, no comparative studies on the effectiveness of different therapeutic approaches for LD are available regarding preventing vertical transmission in pregnancy [95], apart from a large series of pregnant women who had a favorable course and outcome using intravenous ceftriaxone [96]. What is clear however, is that gestational LD appears to be associated with a low risk of adverse pregnancy outcome, particularly with appropriate antibiotic therapy [93]. In one case study reported by Horowitz [97], a healthy woman with a history of Lyme disease who was previously treated with several months of antibiotics miscarried at week eighteen when she was no longer on antibiotics, and both the placenta and fetus were positive for PCR evidence of B. burgdorferi. As per the CDC, "Lyme disease acquired during pregnancy may lead to infection of the placenta and possible stillbirth; however, no negative effects on the fetus have been found when the mother receives appropriate antibiotic treatment" [98].
According to US Preventative Services Task Force, all women should be screened serologically early on in pregnancy for syphilis, another spirochetal infection [99], due to the possibility of stillbirth, neonatal death and neurologic impairment [99]. These are some of the same symptoms reported in congenital Lyme disease, another spirochetal infection [38,92]. Treatment of syphilis involves intramuscular injection of long acting Benzathine penicillin G (2.4 million units administered intramuscularly) for primary, secondary or early latent syphilis and has been found to be effective [100]. Since B. burgdorferi has been found in a newborn despite the use of oral penicillin for Lyme borreliosis during pregnancy [34], and as Bicillin injections have been found effective in the treatment of both Lyme arthritis [101,102] and other resistant symptoms of LD (chronic fatigue, myalgias, arthralgias, headaches, paresthesias and cognitive difficulties) unresponsive to oral therapy [103], we decided to institute IM benzathine penicillin after an informed discussion of the risks and benefits.
Our patient was on intramuscular benzathine penicillin (Bicillin) throughout her four pregnancies, ranging from 2.4 to 4.8 million U IM/week with no adverse outcomes in the fetus, and the route of administration of antibiotic therapy has been shown to play a role in pregnancy outcomes. In a study of 95 women with Lyme borreliosis during pregnancy, adverse outcomes were seen in 12.1% of parentally treated women, 31.6% of orally treated women, and 60% untreated women [104]. In comparison to patients treated with antibiotics, untreated women had a significantly higher risk of adverse pregnancy outcome (odds ratio [OR] 7.61, p=0.004). The advantage of benzathine penicillin intramuscularly is that parenteral penicillin therapy has been shown to be effective in the treatment of Lyme disease and Lyme arthritis [101,102], and as opposed to oral regimens with varying peak and trough levels, sustained therapeutic levels of benzathine penicillin may be effective by inhibition of germ replication or by lysis of the spirochetes leaving their sanctuaries [102]. This may have contributed to healthy outcomes in all four newborns.
Despite ongoing treatment, our patient had frequent complaints of symptoms of fatigue, migratory joint pain, neuralgia, severe headaches, and cognitive difficulties. These are all part of the classic constellation of symptoms seen with Lyme disease [105,106], although it is possible that she also suffered from occult bartonellosis with her history of unexplained striae (Figure 2), Herxheimer flares with rifampin, high 1-25 OH/25 OH Vitamin D ratios (consistent with an active intracellular infection) [107,108], and resistant symptoms. The type of striae seen on her physical examination have been found to be associated with bartonella [109,110], and laboratory testing in New York only allowed evaluation of two species, B. henselae and B. quintana, although 36 different Bartonella species have now been discovered [50], and at least seventeen of them have been associated with an expanding spectrum of human diseases [111]. Bartonella may complicate and worsen clinical presentations. Bartonella species were recently found in 46.6% of Lyme patients with rheumatological symptoms in one case series [112], and 46.5% of neurologically impaired Lyme patients in a recent 2019 retrospective chart review [113].
Our patient also frequently complained of drenching day and night sweats, chills, flushing, an unexplained cough and shortness of breath described as 'air hunger'. These are commonly experienced symptoms in patients infected with babesiosis [105]. Laboratory diagnosis Arch Med Case Rep. 2020 Volume 2, Issue 1 of babesiosis is typically made by examination of peripheral thick and thin blood smears using Giemsa staining, visualizing ring forms and Maltese cross forms (smears can be negative with low levels of parasitemia), as well as serology (IFA, ELISA), culture and nucleic acid amplification (PCR, RNA) and sequencing [114]. FISH staining of blood smears has also proven effective [115]. Our patient had evidence of exposure to B. microti with a fourfold rise in titer over time and multiple positive FISH tests, proving persistence [116]. She also had a positive antibody titer to B. duncani, a species primarily found on the west coast. The patient did live in California for several years before moving to the eastern seaboard but did not report a known tick bite during that time. It is possible that she was exposed to several different Babesia species, as two recent reports have indicated the probable spread of B. duncani across the US as well as Canada [113,117,118]. It is also possible that her B. duncani test represented cross reactivity with B. microti, as only 13 confirmed cases have been reported to date by the CDC [113,119], although antibody responses among the three dominant human pathogens of humans, B. microti, B. duncani, and B. divergens appear to be species specific [120].
Epidemiological studies have demonstrated that babesiosis is spreading in the United States [121,122] and Europe [123][124][125], and that simultaneous infection with B. microti and B. burgdorferi are now the most common tick-transmitted coinfections in the U.S. [122,126,127]. B. microti-B. burgdorferi coinfected patients suffer from significantly more diverse and intense symptoms, which persist longer than those in patients infected with each pathogen individually [128]. Several reasons may exist for the increased severity of illness. It has been suggested that coinfection not only increases the severity of disease, but also may impair host defense mechanisms [129]. In support of this hypothesis, patients with coinfections report a longer duration of illness and exacerbated symptoms including fatigue, myalgia, sweats and erythema migrans [128,130]. Our patient complained of resistant fatigue, myalgias, arthralgias, sweats and an ACA rash. Co-infection has also been reported to result in a death from pancarditis [131]. Impaired host defense mechanisms have been described in detail for babesiosis [126]. The adaptive immune system and a strong TH1 response increasing production of IFN-γ is needed to combat intracellular pathogens and Babesia, while a strong Th2 response with an increase in IL-4 production and B cell production of antibodies is essential for host defense against extracellular pathogens and Lyme disease [132]. A robust B cell response has also been shown to be necessary for rapid resolution of Lyme disease [133], and in the acute phase of co-infection in the mouse model, marginal zone disruption of the spleen and B cell atrophy were seen where B. microti infection ultimately resulted in reduction in splenic B cells and pathogen specific antibody production [126,134]. B. burgdorferi infection has also been shown to attenuate parasitemia in mice while B. microti subverts the splenic immune response, leading to a marked decrease in splenic B and T cells, reduction in antibody levels and diminished functional humoral immunity [135]. Clearance of both pathogens could therefore be impaired by imbalances in the immune system.
Infection with B. burgdorferi has previously been shown in the mouse model to cause a T cell independent response in the lymph nodes where there is a lack of strongly induced, protective borrelia-specific IgG antibodies [136]. Suppression of a long-lived humoral immunity following an infection with B. burgdorferi ultimately results in a temporary immunosuppression of the host where early germinal centers systemically fail to produce antigen-specific memory B cells [137]. This can result in elevations of IgM antibodies and a decrease in IgG protective antibodies. The same type of immune deficiencies has been reported in humans infected with B. burgdorferi and/or co-infected with babesiosis [113]. This could potentially explain our patient's four-fold rise in IgM titers to B. microti over time, with evidence of persistent Babesia by RNA analysis (FISH), without significant production of protective IgG antibodies.
Numerous studies highlight immune suppression in pregnancy, where progesterone can act as a natural immune suppressor [138]. Advanced age, splenectomy and immune suppression all increase the risk of critical outcomes with Babesia [119]. Pregnant women have also been shown to be more severely affected by infections with certain organisms vs. non-pregnant women, including the influenza virus, hepatitis E virus (HEV), herpes simplex virus (HSV) and the malaria parasite [139]. Babesiosis and malaria are both intraerythrocytic parasitic infections and share certain similar clinical characteristics, including febrile hemolytic anemia [140]. Considering the risk of immunosuppression in pregnancy with the possibility of transplacental infection and congenital babesiosis, certain authors have therefore advocated for the treatment of all pregnant women diagnosed with babesiosis, even if asymptomatic [25].
Babesiosis in pregnancy can also imitate HELLP syndrome [25] which is an important differential diagnosis, since both diseases can result in hemolysis, elevated liver functions and low platelet counts. Our patient only had evidence of very mild anemia later in her pregnancies (normally seen in pregnancy with hemodilution) with very mild thrombocytopenia (platelet counts ranging between 116,000/UL and 130,000/UL [normal range 140-400,000/UL)] and normal liver and kidney functions. There was no evidence of hemolytic anemia, even though her initial exposure to Babesia was in Europe, where the European species B. divergens has been shown to be more highly associated with hemolytic anemia [141]. Babesiosis can also result in symptoms ranging from mild anemia, to severe pancytopenia, with complications including splenic rupture, disseminated intravascular coagulopathy (DIC), hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis (HLH) [142], and acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) [143], as well as warm autoimmune hemolytic anemia (WAHA) [144]. Congenital babesiosis in the fetus can result in anemia, neutropenia, and thrombocytopenia [13], with fevers, jaundice, and hepatosplenomegaly [16]. Apart from following the pregnancy with a highrisk OB/GYN, the pediatric team should be alerted to a history of maternal babesiosis, so appropriate blood work and close surveillance are performed postdelivery.
In our patient, all four children were healthy at delivery with no signs or symptoms of borreliosis or babesiosis. Clindamycin with quinine is one of the most common treatments for babesiosis in pregnancy, due to good placental penetration and evidence of decreased vertical transmission to the fetus [12]. Transplacental passage of azithromycin was initially postulated to occur at low rates [145], but further pharmacokinetic studies have proven adequate penetration into the amniotic fluid with adequate doses, dosing intervals and duration of therapy [146]. Azithromycin in higher doses as monotherapy have also been shown to be efficacious in treating B. microti in the animal model [147].
We chose atovaquone and azithromycin as it has been shown to be as effective as clindamycin and quinine for both mild and severe infections [22,148], with less potential side effects. For example, quinine may induce nausea, vomiting, rashes, and QT prolongation with torsade de point [149]. Both regimens however may be inadequate to completely clear the parasitic infection [150]. A 2019 study by Abittan et al., found clindamycin and quinine as well as atovaquone and azithromycin to be ineffective in treating babesiosis during pregnancy [24]. That was our experience as well. Our patient continuously relapsed with signs and symptoms of active babesiosis with multiple positive FISH (RNA) tests before and during her pregnancy despite long term use of atovaquone and azithromycin. Clindamycin was also used for 10 days during the third trimester of her third pregnancy along with atovaquone and azithromycin for resistant symptoms. This was helpful in relieving her symptomatology and preventing vertical transmission but was not curative.  [154,155]. Those at highest risk are patients with immunodeficiencies resulting from B-cell lymphomas, organ transplants, HIV/AIDS, or treatment with immunosuppressive drugs such as Rituximab [156][157][158][159] and severe disease can also be seen in hospitalized patients with concurrent chronic illnesses, including diabetes, congestive heart failure (CHF) and renal failure [160]. Yet babesiosis may be fatal even in those with no clear underlying medical problems, especially when transmitted by blood transfusion. [4,156,161].
Lyme disease patients co-infected with Babesia spp. oftentimes are sicker and more resistant to therapy [157,162], and this is especially the case in pregnancy when underlying immunosuppression is present [128,151,154,163]. Recently a pregnant patient with babesiosis who failed clindamycin and quinine as well as atovaquone and azithromycin required an exchange transfusion [24]. Other treatments that have been shown to be helpful in certain cases of resistant babesiosis, including the use of higher dose Bactrim [164], mefloquine [165], atovaquone/proguanil, artemisinin derivatives and dapsone [119,166-168] are contraindicated during pregnancy. Similarly, disulfiram [169] and tafenoquine [170] which have the potential to treat resistant babesiosis are unable to be used due to potential toxicity in the fetus. Novel and more effective treatments for resistant babesiosis are urgently needed.
In our patient, we used higher doses of atovaquone (two teaspoons BID, i.e., 1500 mg BID) combined with azithromycin during all four pregnancies to try and overcome resistance to standard drug regimens. Clindamycin was also used in combination with atovaquone and azithromycin during the third pregnancy. Combination therapies have previously been shown to be superior to monotherapy [147], and our use of higher doses of atovaquone with azithromycin and clindamycin proved to be effective in preventing congenital transmission, even if ineffective in clearing Babesia in the mother. Atovaquone used alone can cause drug resistance but evidence that clindamycin and atovaquone with azithromycin can effectively treat Babesia has previously been reported in both animals [171], and humans [172], although there is now greater recognition of resistance to standard Babesia regimens [153,163], especially in immunocompromised patients with babesiosis when 6 weeks of therapy or longer may be necessary [172]. During Consecutive Pregnancies: A Case Study and Literature Review. Arch Med Case Rep. 2020; 2(1): 1-19. Arch Med Case Rep. 2020 Volume 2, Issue 1 At birth, none of the neonates of our patient demonstrated signs of active infection with Lyme or babesiosis during pediatric follow-up. Follow-up ranged from 1-10 years. In prior case series of congenitally transmitted babesiosis among 9 children [13] most mothers were unaware of being infected and therefore were not treated, leading to increased morbidity in the neonates who presented with fever, hemolytic anemia, thrombocytopenia and neutropenia [13].

Conclusion
Considering the significant increase in exposure to Lyme disease in the United States in the past decade [173][174][175] as well as the increase in cases of babesiosis [127,176,177] it is important for all women of childbearing age to be aware of the risks of congenital transmission of tick-borne diseases and to take appropriate preventative measures. A screening questionnaire to establish the pre-test possibility of tick-borne infection before and during pregnancy could be useful [105], as well as determining optimal testing and management approaches [24,178]. Penicillins, cephalosporins, macrolides, clindamycin, quinine and atovaquone may all be used in pregnancy [91,[179][180][181][182][183], although high dose quinine should be avoided in the first trimester secondary to the possibility of spontaneous abortion [12].
Our case report is the first one to our knowledge to describe both the safe and effective use of IM benzathine penicillin and azithromycin in four consecutive pregnancies to prevent vertical transmission of LD, along with high dose atovaquone and azithromycin (with or without clindamycin) to prevent vertical transmission of babesiosis. Future research into effective treatments of Lyme disease and babesiosis in both the pregnant and non-pregnant patient is urgently needed due to the possible relapsing, remitting nature of both diseases and potential for associated morbidity and mortality.

Disclaimer
The views expressed are those of Dr. Richard Horowitz, and do not represent the views of the Tick-Borne Disease Working Group, HHS or the United States.