Navigating the Adipocyte Precursor Niche: Cell-Cell Interactions, Regulatory Mechanisms and Implications for Adipose Tissue Homeostasis

Support for stem cell self-renewal and differentiation hinges upon the intricate microenvironment termed the stem cell ‘niche’. Within the adipose tissue stem cell niche, diverse cell types, such as endothelial cells, immune cells, mural cells, and adipocytes, intricately regulate the function of adipocyte precursors. These interactions, whether direct or indirect, play a pivotal role in governing the balance between self-renewal and differentiation of adipocyte precursors into adipocytes. The mechanisms orchestrating the maintenance and coordination of this niche are still in the early stages of comprehension, despite their crucial role in regulating adipose tissue homeostasis. The complexity of understanding adipocyte precursor renewal and differentiation is amplified due to the challenges posed by the absence of suitable surface receptors for identification, limitations in creating optimal ex vivo culture conditions for expansion and constraints in conducting in vivo studies. This review delves into the current landscape of knowledge surrounding adipocyte precursors within the adipose stem cell niche. We will review the identification of adipocyte precursors, the cell-cell interactions they engage in, the factors influencing their renewal and commitment toward adipocytes and the transformations they undergo during instances of obesity.


Introduction
Understanding the regulation of adipose tissue holds significant clinical importance, given the association between obesity and an elevated risk of diabetes, stroke, heart disease, and cancer, leading to increased healthcare expenses and reduced life expectancy [1].According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National Diabetes Statistics Report, among US adults aged 18 years or older with diagnosed diabetes, 89.8% were overweight or obese, making this the largest risk factor for developing diabetes [2].
The global surge in obesity is at least in part attributed to the consumption of highcaloric food combined with a sedentary lifestyle [3].Traditional approaches like diet and exercise often fall short of achieving long-term weight loss due to biological adaptations in chronically obese individuals [4].Consequently, there is a pressing need to develop innovative therapeutic strategies to address the public health risks associated with obesity.
The onset of weight gain and obesity is driven by prolonged periods of food excess, creating a positive energy balance and excessive lipid storage in adipose tissue.This process results in inflammation, cellular stress, insulin resistance, and the potential development of diabetes [5].Obesity triggers complex changes in adipose tissue, leading to hyperplasia and hypertrophy of adipocytes, with lipid accumulation in visceral depots due to reduced adipogenic capacity [6].A hallmark of obesity-related adipose tissue is persistent low-grade inflammation, characterized by elevated levels of immune cells such as T cells, B cells, macrophages, neutrophils, and mast cells [7].In lean adipose tissue, M2 macrophages dominate, conferring anti-inflammatory effects, while in obesity, M1 macrophages prevail, releasing pro-inflammatory cytokines that induce insulin resistance [8].Depletion of adipose tissue macrophages improves insulin sensitivity, with visceral adipose tissue showing a higher recruitment of pro-inflammatory macrophages compared to subcutaneous tissue [9][10][11].Additionally, obesity leads to a decrease in regulatory CD4 helper T cells and an increase in CD8 T cells in visceral adipose tissue [12][13][14].Eosinophils play a role in adipocyte browning, and their loss during obesity exacerbates diet-induced weight gain [15].Obesity also reduces adipose tissue capillarization, potentially worsening insulin resistance and adipocyte dysfunction [6].Increasing VEGF-mediated angiogenesis in adipose tissue can mitigate metabolic consequences of obesity, such as insulin resistance and hepatic steatosis [16,17].In addition, adipose tissue inflammation is fueled by heightened secretion of TNF-α and free fatty acids from enlarged adipocytes, which impairs insulin sensitivity and triggers adipocyte lipolysis [18].Moreover, TNF-α compounds insulin resistance by suppressing key genes involved in adipocyte development and insulin signaling [19].These disruptions in adipose tissue function not only contribute to the prevalence of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease in obese, insulin-resistant, and diabetic individuals but also impact insulin secretion by inhibiting β-cell potassium channels and altering ATP production [18].Meanwhile, the adipokine profile of visceral white adipose tissue (WAT) serves as a critical determinant of cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk, with adiponectin playing a protective role through cholesterol reduction, inflammation suppression, and AMPK activation [20][21][22].Conversely, lower plasma adiponectin levels in CVD patients, along with the presence of resistin and FGF21, signify elevated risk factors associated with obesity, type 2 diabetes, and atherosclerosis development, driven by increased TNF-α levels in serum and adipose tissue [23][24][25][26][27].
During healthy conditions, adipose tissue serves multiple functions, including structural support to organs, protection from cold, and crucially, regulating energy balance and metabolic homeostasis [28].Both humans and rodents possess white adipose tissue (WAT) responsible for energy storage, with its accumulation correlating with metabolic syndrome in overweight individuals.Conversely, brown adipose tissue (BAT) converts stored lipids into heat and exhibits a positive correlation with a reduced risk of metabolic syndrome, making it a promising therapeutic target [1].Apart from the conventional BAT depot situated in the interscapular region, functionally analogous "beige" adipose tissue can be induced within adult subcutaneous white adipose tissue (WAT) in response to cold-induced norepinephrine secretion via the sympathetic nervous system.The generation of beige adipose tissue within subcutaneous WAT signifies a dynamic adaptation, revealing the plasticity of adipose tissue and its ability to respond to environmental cues by adopting characteristics similar to those of thermogenic BAT [29].Gaining insight into the biological mechanisms governing the development and maintenance of white, brown, and beige adipose tissues is crucial for developing targeted interventions and therapeutic strategies to prevent and treat metabolic disorders.
Within a tissue, a stem cell niche establishes a specialized microenvironment where direct cell-cell interactions and molecular signals sustain stem cells in an undifferentiated state or facilitate their differentiation.In particular, the adipose stem cell niche comprises various cell types, including adipocytes, multipotent adipose-derived stem cells (ASCs or ADSCs), committed adipocyte progenitors (APs), endothelial cells, fibroblasts, immune cells, and vascular smooth muscle cells.These cells communicate through direct interactions or paracrine signaling via adipokine secretion [30].This review provides an overview of the adipose stem cell niche, with a focus on characterizing ASCs and APs, exploring their interactions with other cell types in the niche, examining their molecular regulation, and investigating the changes they undergo in response to increased adiposity, which may contribute to the development of obesity-related disorders.

Fraction
The stromal vascular fraction (SVF) refers to a heterogeneous mixture of cells that can be isolated from adipose tissue through enzymatic digestion.This fraction excludes mature adipocytes and consists of a variety of cell types, including ASCs, APs, fibroblasts, immune cells, endothelial cells, epithelial cells, and other cells associated with the circulatory and nervous systems [31].The SVF is particularly rich in stromal and vascular components, and its diverse cell population makes it a valuable source for regenerative and therapeutic applications in medical research and clinical settings [32].Stem cells and progenitor cells are frequently used interchangeably, yet their definitions are contentious and continue to evolve [33].Stem cells are characterized by distinct features such as pluripotency and the capacity for unlimited replication.Conversely, progenitor cells, while still possessing replicative abilities, are more limited in replication and are further along the differentiation path as they have committed to a specific lineage.The absence of appropriate culture conditions for assessing replicative capacity and the scarcity of distinctive surface markers have posed challenges in differentiating between stem and progenitor cells originating from the adipose tissue niche.In the context of this review, the term ASCs will specifically denote the subset of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) residing in adipose tissue, possessing multilineage potential to differentiate into adipocytes, osteoblasts, chondrocytes, and other lineages, which constitute less than 0.1% of all SVF cells [34,35].On the other hand, APs, also known as preadipocytes, will refer to cells committed to the adipocyte lineage, typically constituting 15%−35% of the SVF [34][35][36][37].It's crucial to note that APs frequently exhibit a similar cell surface phenotype to ASCs (unless specified otherwise), although they might display markers indicating commitment to the adipocyte lineage, such as expression of PPARγ [35].Finally, within this review, the term "adipocyte precursors" will broadly encompass any cell within the niche possessing the potential to become adipogenic, encompassing ASCs, adipocyte progenitors, and potentially other cell varieties.

Adipose Tissue Dynamics, Differentiation, and Metabolic Regulation
Adipose tissue exhibits a distinctive capacity to expand and contract in response to various physiological conditions, including instances of overeating, dietary changes, and physical exercise.This dynamic nature underscores its crucial role in energy storage and metabolic regulation within the body.Additionally, the adaptability of adipose tissue plays a key role in maintaining overall homeostasis and responding to the fluctuating energy demands imposed by different lifestyle and dietary factors.In general, the expansion of subcutaneous WAT is linked to a lower susceptibility to cardiometabolic syndrome during obesity, highlighting its potential protective role.Conversely, the expansion of visceral WAT is frequently correlated with insulin resistance and an increased risk of developing diabetes [38,39].This distinction underscores the importance of considering not only the overall adipose tissue mass but also the specific depots, as their responses may have distinct implications for metabolic health.The enlargement of adipose tissue mass can result from hyperplasia, involving an augmentation in the number of adipocyte cells, which is generally considered more metabolically advantageous than hypertrophy, where adipocyte cell size increases due to heightened lipid storage [40].In adults, the quantity of adipocytes remains relatively consistent in both lean and obese individuals, with approximately 10% of mature adipocytes being replenished annually through the differentiation of adipocyte precursors [41,42].
The initial stage of adipocyte differentiation is initiated when ASCs respond to external signals, prompting them to transform into APs with a specific commitment to the adipocyte lineage.Subsequently, in the second phase, the terminal differentiation of committed APs into fully mature adipocytes, characterized by cell cycle arrest, involves a coordinated series of transcriptional events primarily governed by CCAAT-enhancer-binding proteins (C/EBPs), sterol regulatory element binding protein 1c (SREBP1c) and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma (PPARγ) [43][44][45][46].PPARγ serves as the principal regulator of adipogenesis, playing a pivotal role in orchestrating the process.Ablation of PPARγ has been shown to hinder adipogenesis and prevents the development of adipose tissue in mice [47,48].C/EBPs and SREBPc1 induce the expression of PPARγ, which then directly interacts with retinoid X receptor (RXR).This interaction enables the binding of the PPARγ-RXR complex to responsive regulatory elements, leading to the activation of genes involved in adipogenesis, lipid metabolism, inflammation, and the maintenance of metabolic homeostasis [46,49,50].Upon formation, mature adipocytes acquire the molecular machinery required for lipid and glucose transport, insulin responsiveness, and the secretion of paracrine factors, collectively contributing to the regulation of systemic metabolic homeostasis [43].
In contrast to white adipocytes, brown and beige adipocytes exhibit distinct transcription factors that govern their differentiation and function.These include the expression of PR domain zinc finger protein 16 (PRDM16), early B cell factor 2 (EBF2) and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma coactivator 1-alpha (PGC-1α) (reviewed in Ref. [44]).These transcription factors, in collaboration with PPARγ, orchestrate an elevation in the expression of uncoupling protein-1 (UCP1) and facilitate the activation of UCP1-mediated thermogenic responses in response to β-adrenergic receptor stimuli.

Advantages of Immortalized Adipocyte Precursor Cell Lines
The notion that adipocytes could emerge from a pool of stem/progenitor cells gained prominence during the refinement of techniques for segregating adipose tissue into adipocytes and the SVF (reviewed in [31]).These investigations revealed that adherent fibroblast-like cells within the SVF exhibited competence for adipogenesis, leading to their subsequent classification as preadipocytes [51][52][53].As the SVF can give rise to cell types beyond adipocytes, such as osteoblasts, chondrocytes, and myoblasts, these cultures likely represent the coexistence of multipotent MSCs alongside solely committed APs [31].For a deeper understanding of adipocyte differentiation and cellular physiology, as well as to address challenges linked to the variable differentiation and premature senescence of SVF cells, numerous immortalized, clonal AP cell lines have been developed.For instance, immortalized 3T3-L1 cells, developed from mouse embryonic fibroblasts in the 1970s, are recognized as a committed AP cell line.These cells were instrumental in elucidating that the transcription factor PPARγ acts as the primary regulator of adipocyte differentiation and collaborates with C/EBPα to stimulate adipogenesis [54][55][56][57].3T3-L1 APs are generally acknowledged as committed to the development of mature white adipocytes and are thought to possess a limited capacity for thermogenesis.However, the extent of this thermogenic potential has been a topic of debate since the cells were first derived [58].Cell lines like the mouse-derived HIB-1B and "Thermomouse" lines, originating from interscapular BAT, exhibit a robust thermogenic program, serving as invaluable tools to dissect mechanisms involved in brown adipose tissue thermogenesis [59,60].The extent to which these immortalized cell lines accurately represent a specific progenitor type found within the native adipose tissue niche, when compared to primary isolated adipocyte progenitors APs from distinct adipose tissue depots, remains unclear.

Immunophenotyping
The predominant approach for discerning adipocyte precursors from other cell types in the adipose tissue niche has been through the analysis of cell surface markers.However, identifying, and characterizing adipocyte precursors within the SVF has posed challenges for several reasons.Firstly, diverse developmental origins are known to give rise to anatomically distinct adipocytes, including white, beige, and brown subtypes.This implies that specific developmental programming may lead to distinct precursor lineages, each giving rise to a particular type of adipocyte.Additionally, during SVF culture, surface marker expression may undergo changes, complicating the establishment of a definitive marker profile [31].Discrepancies in surface marker expression have also emerged between human and rodent studies, and numerous surface markers may lack specificity for adipocyte precursors, being expressed on non-stem cell lineages [31].Moreover, surface marker profiles may vary or overlap between ASCs and more committed APs.These complexities contribute to the challenge of establishing a definitive adipocyte precursor cell surface marker profile.Nonetheless, several markers have proven valuable in studying these cells and enriching populations with substantial adipogenic potential.
CD34 serves as a prevalent MSC marker expressed on ASCs exhibiting high adipogenic potential.Utilizing CD34, in conjunction with depleting common endothelial (CD31) and hematopoietic (CD45) markers, proves effective in enriching ASCs from the SVF [61,62].However, potential inconsistency in results with CD34 may arise due to its downregulation post-cell culture [31,63].CD29 and Sca1 (specific to mice) are also recognized as common MSC markers suitable for identifying and enriching ASCs.Notably, Friedman et al. outlined a subset of undifferentiated ASCs marked by CD29+, CD34+, Sca-1+, CD24+, demonstrating the capability to proliferate and differentiate into adipocytes [34].These precursors are also capable of restoring a fully functional and normal WAT depot and effectively reverse diabetic phenotypes seen in lipodystrophic mice [34].CD24 has been employed to distinguish hierarchical populations of adipocyte precursors, revealing varying levels of commitment and potential [64].In adipose depots displaying a hyperplastic response, CD24+ ASCs undergo rapid and transient proliferation shortly after the initiation of a high-fat diet [65].Furthermore, CD24+ ASCs represent a more primitive multipotent stem cell population.As cells initiate the expression of adipocyte lineage-selective genes like Pparγ and C/ebpα, indicative of a more committed stage in adipogenesis, CD24 expression is lost [64,66].

Adipocyte precursor positioning within the extracellular matrix of adipose tissue
In the adult, adipose tissue comprises distinct lobules characterized by clusters of adipocytes separated by extracellular matrix (ECM), forming defined partitions known as septa [67] (Figures 1A and 1B).Both mathematical modeling and experimental findings propose that these lobules spontaneously emerge through mechanical interactions between adipocytes and fibers within the ECM [68].Recent evidence indicates that adipose tissue lobules consist of two structurally distinct ECM compartments: the septa, lining the exterior of the lobule, and the internal stroma ECM (Figure 1C) [69].These compartments house unique subsets of CD34+ precursor cells, with a highly adipogenic committed MSCA1+/ CD271− progenitor subset enriched in the stroma, and an MSCA1−/CD271 hi subset present in the septa, marking myofibroblast precursors potentially contributing to fibrous septa formation (Figures 1D and 1E) [69].In the stroma, APs are discernible from pericytes and are positioned not within capillary walls but between adipocytes or in proximity to the vasculature [69].Notably, in humans, inherent differences exist within these progenitor subsets concerning their adipogenic and myofibroblastic capacities in stroma and septa niches.This includes a higher myofibroblastic capacity in visceral WAT compared to subcutaneous WAT during obesity, potentially contributing to fibrosis [69].

Adipocyte precursors within the mural cell compartment
Early morphological investigations have indicated the close association of adipocyte development with the vasculature, prompting the proposal that pericytes, a subset of mural cells known for modulating endothelial cell functions, vessel contractility, and possessing multipotent MSC characteristics, may also serve as a precursor population for adipocytes (Figure 1F) [67,[70][71][72].In their quest to identify committed APs within the adipose tissue niche, Tang et al. postulated that these cells would exhibit the expression of PPARγ, a pivotal regulator in the formation of adipocytes [37,73].Using a Pparγ reporter strain, they demonstrated that Pparγ+ cells are present in PECAM+ (CD31) blood vessel walls of WAT, exhibiting high adipogenic potential and expressing mural cell markers, including α-SMA, PDGFRβ, and NG2 [37].Most of the committed Pparγ+ APs co-expressed Sca1 and CD34, but lacked expression of CD105 (MSCs), CD45 (immune cells), TER-119 (erythrocytes) or Mac-1 (monocytes).Notably, APs expressing Pparγ from the mural cell compartment were absent in the vessel walls of other tissues (such as skeletal and cardiac muscle, kidney, retina, pancreas, spleen and lung).Furthermore, the mural cells within these additional tissues did not demonstrate a notable capacity for high adipogenic potential [37].Moreover, lineage tracing experiments provided evidence that adipose tissue can originate from mural cells expressing Pdgfrβ.When transplanted into nude mice, these Pdgfrβ+ mural cells exhibited substantial adipogenic potential [37].In a subsequent investigation employing a doxycycline-inducible tracking system for mural cell lineage based on Pdgfrβ expression, it was demonstrated that these perivascular APs also play a role in promoting adipocyte hyperplasia in visceral WAT during high-fat diet feeding [74].In summary, these findings indicate the presence of a distinct population of APs situated within the mural cell compartment of adipose tissue.
Recent research has utilized Cre drivers specific to vascular smooth muscle cells (Myh11, α-Sma) and mural cells (Pdgfrβ) to reveal that certain subgroups of beige adipocytes can also be traced back to the mural cell compartment [74][75][76].In our laboratory, research has been directed towards the generation of beige adipocytes from induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) [77].These adipocytes originate from the splanchnic mesoderm, an embryonic tissue recognized for its capacity to generate mural and vascular smooth muscle cells [78].Our results showed that MSCs originating from the splanchnic mesoderm exhibit positivity for α-SMA, PDGFRβ and NG2.These MSCs give rise to UCP1+ adipocytes that showcase the distinctive gene expression profile associated with beige adipocytes (CITED1+, CD137+, TMEM26+).Notably, this gene expression signature differs from that of classical brown adipocytes, which typically express ZIC1 and a myogenic skeletal muscle signature [77,78].Remarkably, beige adipocyte precursors originating from mural cells (α-SMA+) in mice display a senescence-like phenotype by the age of 6 months, hindering beige adipocyte formation during cold exposure [79].Corresponding outcomes in this study were observed in beige precursors derived from elderly human patients.Intervening pharmacologically in the senescence-like process proved effective in revitalizing dysfunctional aged beige precursors, enabling them to resume beige adipogenesis.In mice, this intervention resulted in a simultaneous reduction in blood glucose levels.This underscores the significance of identifying specific subgroups of adipocyte precursors for targeted interventions aimed at enhancing metabolic health.

Adipocyte precursors derived from fibroblastic cells
Further lineage tracing investigations have revealed the presence of additional APs that exist beyond the confines of the mural cell compartment.PDGFRα serves as a broad fibroblast marker found on cells identified as progenitors across diverse mesenchymal tissues [80].In WAT, progenitors marked by PDGFRα constitute a subset within the adipocyte precursor compartment characterized by CD34 and Sca-1, displaying bipotential capabilities [36].These cells undergo proliferation and have the capacity to generate white adipocytes under normal conditions or during high-fat feeding.Alternatively, upon pharmacological stimulation of the β3-adrenergic receptor (ADRB3), they can produce beige adipocytes [36].It has been observed that PDGFRα+ APs are situated in proximity to the vasculature, featuring extensive dendritic processes that establish contact with multiple cells in the tissue environment [36].In this study, PDGFRα+ APs in WAT were demonstrated to lack expression of PPARγ, α-SMA and PDGFRβ, indicating their location outside the mural cell compartment [36].Notably, in a subsequent investigation, the researchers illustrated that APs marked by PDGFRα+ in subcutaneous WAT could be prompted to undergo differentiation into beige adipocytes through acute cold exposure (1 week) [81].Conversely, it has been demonstrated that a duration of two weeks of cold exposure is required to facilitate the development of beige adipocytes from mural APs marked by PDGFRβ [74,75].Thus, adipose precursors identified by PDGFRα+ in WAT may be functionally differentiated from those in the mural cell compartment by their capacity to promptly react to metabolic stress.Consequently, beige adipogenesis might hinge on various adipocyte precursor populations, each with their own specific timing and activation events [64].
Newly available information is elucidating the distinctions between mural (PDGFRβ+) and fibroblastic (PDGFRα+) sources of adipogenic precursors, along with their respective roles in adipose tissue development under conditions such as high-fat diet, browning, and regular metabolic homeostasis [82].By employing three distinct Cre drivers-Tie2-Cre for hematopoietic and endothelial cells, Tbx18Cre-ERT2 for mural cells (pericytes and vascular smooth muscle cells), and Pdgfrα-MerCreMer for adipose tissue fibroblasts-it was demonstrated that only adipose tissue fibroblasts located within the blood vessel adventitia and adipose tissue capsule regions were notably involved in de novo adipogenesis among the various cell types within the vascular wall [82].Significantly, these findings illustrated that PDGFRβ not only identifies mural cells but also marks adventitial PDGFRα+ APs, potentially providing insights into the reasons behind previous studies indicating a potential involvement of mural cells (Figure 1G) [82].Additional investigations corroborate this inference, as single-cell RNA sequencing has revealed that APs express both PDGFRα and PDGFRβ [83].The findings from our research using multipotent, human iPSC-derived mural cells also indicated that as these cells transitioned into committed APs, they gained PDGFRα expression concurrent with heightened PPARγ expression [77].Nevertheless, it is yet to be elucidated whether PDGFRβ+ mural cells have the capacity to generate double-positive PDGFRα/PDGFRβ APs in the course of in vivo adipocyte development.
Additionally, there is a need to investigate potential variations in the expression of these markers between mice and humans during de novo adipogenesis.Utilizing single-cell RNA sequencing analysis to identify beige adipocyte precursors, Oguri et al. discovered that CD81 serves as a marker for a novel subset of PDGFRα+ stromal cells expressing a smooth muscle-like signature, including α-SMA, Sm22, Myl9, and Myh11 [84].This subset of APs is characterized by high proliferative activity and gives rise to beige adipocytes.CD81 was also identified as a functional regulator of beige adipocyte precursor proliferation through irisin-mediated FAK signaling.In murine models, CD81 was demonstrated to be essential for de novo beige fat biogenesis, and its deletion resulted in diet-induced obesity, glucose intolerance, and adipose tissue dysfunction.Additionally, in humans, a decreased count of CD81 + adipocyte precursors in subcutaneous WAT was shown to be indicative of metabolic risk, including elevated fasting blood glucose levels, diastolic blood pressure, visceral fat mass, and visceral adiposity.Overall, the exploration of cell surface marker profiles linked to different subsets of adipocyte precursors is an ongoing process, evolving as newly identified populations continue to emerge.

Adipocyte Precursor Interactions with Other Cells and Their Influence within the Adipose Tissue Niche
Adipocyte precursors are situated within the perivascular region and stromal component of adipose tissue lobules, engaging in interactions with both mature adipocytes and other cells within the precursor niche in vivo.Our comprehension of the impact of these interactions on the fate of adipocyte precursors and, consequently, adipose tissue homeostasis is still in its nascent stages.In response to various homeostatic and external signals such as weight gain, hypoxia, cold, exercise, and nutrition, mature adipocytes undergo activation and release adipokines that have the potential to influence both energy intake and expenditure [85] and adipocyte precursor differentiation [86].Through experiments with cultured adipocytes or adipose tissue explants, it has been revealed that secreted factors from mature adipocytes can exert either positive or negative regulation on adipocyte differentiation [86].Furthermore, in these studies, the combined secretome of adipose tissue collectively led to the overall inhibition of AP differentiation.It is important to note that, apart from mature adipocytes, other cells within the adipose tissue niche undoubtedly contribute to these processes.
The primary focus of research on cell-cell interactions promoting the maintenance, proliferation, or commitment of adipocyte precursors toward differentiation into mature adipocytes has predominantly centered around cells within isolated SVF.Nonetheless, the mechanism by which the SVF and the adipose tissue niche collectively govern the size and fate determination of the adipocyte precursor pool, thereby influencing adipocyte size, number, and overall adipose homeostasis, remains unclear [87,88].Several constraints in performing this research involve the sharing of markers among various cell populations within the niche, resulting in challenges in distinguishing distinct cell types.Furthermore, the constitution of the separated SVF undergoes substantial alterations during tissue culture expansion, even during the initial stages of passage [89].The primary subsets of nucleated cells residing within the SVF encompass hematopoietic, endothelial, and stromal cells; yet, notable heterogeneity exists among these populations.This diversity is notably influenced by distinct factors, including the specific anatomical localization of adipose tissue, divergent methodologies in tissue processing and culture and the unique health or metabolic constitution of the individual [89,90].For instance, when examining adipocyte precursors isolated from the subcutaneous WAT of individuals with obesity, there emerges an upregulation in the expression of inflammatory genes.This heightened expression correlates with a diminished stemness capacity and an elevated inclination toward committing to adipocyte differentiation [91].Additionally, adipocyte precursors sourced from the subcutaneous WAT of obese patients display a compromised ability to expand and generate beige adipocytes upon induction in cell culture [77,92].These observations highlight the impact of the adipose tissue microenvironment on cellular behavior, particularly in contexts of obesity and altered metabolic states.

Reciprocal interplay between adipocyte precursor and endothelial cell specialization
Due to the proximity of adipocyte precursors to endothelial cells and the integral association between adipose tissue development and angiogenesis, these cell types may undergo regulation via direct cell-cell interactions or through paracrine signaling from endothelial cells [93].This relationship is further exemplified by the proposition that angiogenesis actively recruits adipocyte precursors and induces their differentiation [94].Moreover, in vitro co-culture experiments involving endothelial cells and mature adipocytes have demonstrated a facilitative effect on the development of immature preadipocytes, concurrent with amplified growth of mature adipocytes, which appears to be an indirect consequence of the adhesion between endothelial cells and mature adipocytes [95].The interaction between adipocyte precursors and endothelial cells seems to be bidirectional.Adipocyte precursors play a crucial role in promoting endothelial cell proliferation and differentiation through the secretion of proangiogenic factors, thereby facilitating the formation of blood vessels [89,96].This interaction is further underscored by the discovery that multipotent CD34+ ASCs, isolated from the SVF and characterized by co-expression of mesenchymal (CD90), pericyte (PDGFRβ), and smooth muscle (α-SMA) markers, contribute to the stabilization of the vasculature.These ASCs exhibit a structural and functional association with endothelial cells, leading to enhanced stability of endothelial networks, including improved cord formation [97].Overall, these findings suggest a collaborative and reciprocal relationship between adipocyte differentiation and angiogenesis.

Maintenance and commitment of adipocyte precursors via immunomodulation
Immune cells are integral to the functioning of adipose tissue in both health and disease.In a healthy state, immune mechanisms are essential for maintaining tissue homeostasis through a delicate balance of cell types and signaling pathways, regulating inflammation, supporting tissue repair, and preserving metabolic health [98].The enlargement of adipose tissue during the progression of obesity includes the accumulation of immune cells associated with chronic inflammation and disrupted metabolism, which progressively extends systemically, contributing to insulin resistance and metabolic disorders [5].The secretion of cytokines and growth factors by immune cells may also create a conducive environment for the neovascularization of adipose tissue experiencing ischemia [89].Despite these correlations, the precise function of immune cells within the adipocyte precursor niche during healthy (lean) and diseased (obese) states still requires further elucidation [99].Similar to ASCs, immune cells in the SVF are CD34 positive, but can be discerned from adipocyte precursors by their inability to adhere to culture dishes, resulting in their exclusion during cell culture passage [89].Moreover, distinguishing between immune cells and endothelial cells can be accomplished by observing the absence of the endothelial cell surface marker CD31 in immune cells [90].These distinctions enable researchers to selectively identify and analyze specific immune cell populations, thereby enhancing the precision of understanding their roles within the adipose tissue microenvironment.
Multiple research investigations have demonstrated that cells belonging to the monocyte lineage, such as eosinophils and macrophages, play significant regulatory roles within the adipose tissue niche.Among these, macrophages stand out as the predominant immune cell lineage in adipose tissue, contributing to various functions, including tissue repair, insulin sensitivity, fibrosis, and metabolic homeostasis [99].These macrophages are classified as (M1) pro-inflammatory macrophages, exacerbating insulin resistance, and (M2) antiinflammatory macrophages, enhancing insulin sensitivity [100][101][102].Adipocyte precursors and macrophages engage in interactions, with reported findings indicating that M1 proinflammatory macrophages regulate the expression of angiogenic genes in preadipocytes [103,104].Furthermore, conditioned media from adipose tissue macrophages has been shown to reduce the differentiation capacity of human subcutaneous APs, as evidenced by decreased expression of key adipogenic genes PPARγ2 and C/EBPα [105].Factors derived from pro-inflammatory macrophages, including cytokines like IL-1β and TNFα, may suppress adipogenesis by inhibiting PPARγ expression via NF-κB activation [105].Acutely activated macrophages induce NF-κB activation in APs, possibly due to high levels of TNFα and IL-6, which may increase fibronectin and promote cell proliferation through cyclin D1 induction [105].These findings suggest potential molecular links between macrophage-induced inflammation and altered AP differentiation.Alternative subpopulations of M2 macrophages have been associated positively with beige adipogenesis, implying distinct roles within adipose tissue biology.Cold exposure in mice triggers eosinophil activation in adipose tissue, leading to the secretion of IL-4 and IL-13 cytokines by these cells (Figures 1J and 2A) [106].This secretion polarizes macrophages toward an M2 fate, potentially contributing to the formation of beige adipocytes through catecholamine secretion (Figure 2B) [107].The potential of M2 macrophages to produce enough catecholamines to induce browning of white adipose tissue (WAT) has been a subject of inquiry [108].Despite this, IL-4 secretion by immune cells may directly impact APs from subcutaneous white adipose tissue in mice, fostering beige adipogenesis (Figure 2C) [109,110].Similarly, our laboratory has shown that treating human mural-like adipocyte precursors (α-SMA+/ PDGFRβ+/NG2+) in culture with IL-4 significantly enhances their capacity to generate beige adipocytes (Figure 2C) [77].Additionally, recent research by Nawaz et al. has shown that CD206+ M2 macrophages contribute to preserving the adipogenic precursor pool by preventing exhaustion through overproliferation (Figure 1I) [111].This involves keeping APs in a state of hibernation, preventing unnecessary cell division and potential cell senescence.Specifically, their study revealed that the presence of TGFβ1, expressed by CD206+ M2 macrophages, hinders the proliferation of PDGFRα+ adipogenic precursors (Figure 2D).This observation aligns with previous research indicating that TGFβ signaling serves as a recognized inhibitor of adipogenesis and a suppressor of subcutaneous WAT browning [112,113].Moreover, the depletion of CD206+ M2 macrophages in mice leads to increased browning of WAT in response to cold exposure [111].In summary, the findings from these studies illustrate that M2 macrophages have the potential to impact the adipocyte precursor niche, promoting the maintenance and commitment decisions of adipogenic precursors.

The role of non-adipogenic fibroblasts in adipocyte precursor homeostasis
Investigations in murine models have elucidated the significance of FSP1-expressing fibroblasts as a vital cell type within the niche, crucial for the maintenance and adipogenic potential of APs (Figure 1K) [87].These FSP+ fibroblasts express α-SMA and vimentin, are non-adipogenic, and reside in close proximity to PPARγ+ APs.WNT signaling, pivotal for adipose tissue homeostasis, operates by activating β-catenin and inhibiting AP differentiation [114,115].Activating WNT signaling in FSP1+ fibroblasts led to a gradual reduction in adipose tissue and resistance to diet-induced obesity.This correlated with decreased expression of platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF-BB), vital for maintaining the AP pool.Restoring PDGF-BB levels increased AP percentages and their adipogenic potential.Reduced PDGF-BB signaling affected AP adipogenic capacity by altering how FSP1+ fibroblasts regulated MMP expression and remodeled the ECM in the microenvironment.Thus, FSP1+ fibroblasts play a pivotal role in maintaining adipose tissue homeostasis by creating a microenvironment that governs AP maintenance and adipogenic potential [87].

Fibroblast Growth Factor Maintenance of the Adipocyte Precursor Pool
As ASCs exhibit potential in various regenerative applications, extended culture periods are frequently required to attain an adequate quantity for clinical use.In the cultivation of various stem cell types, FGF-2 is commonly added to the culture medium to enhance the maintenance of self-renewal capacity and plasticity across multiple passages (Figure 1L) [116,117].Culturing adipocyte precursors for extended durations results in diminished capabilities for proliferation, self-renewal, and differentiation.This decline is linked to a reduction in FGF-2 expression by adipocyte precursors, a phenomenon that can be reversed through ongoing treatment with recombinant FGF-2 [117].In alignment with this observation, adipocyte precursors exhibit expression of fibroblast growth factor receptor 1 (FGFR1), displaying a heightened affinity for FGF-2.Blocking this receptor leads to diminished proliferation and deactivation of kinases such as AKT, ERK, JNK, and p38 [118,119].Supplementing adipocyte precursors with FGF-2 before exposure to an adipogenic differentiation cocktail enhances the expression of PPARγ, increasing their capacity to promote adipocyte differentiation [116].Notably, FGF-2 produced by adipocyte precursors is exported to the cell surface without being released into the culture medium, indicating the presence of a functional autocrine loop [117].This becomes pertinent in the context of metabolic disease, as adipocyte precursors derived from subcutaneous and visceral WAT of individuals undergoing bariatric surgery exhibit diminished FGF-2 exportation, which is associated with reduced proliferation, clonogenic potential, and unfavorable metabolic profiles [120].It is noteworthy that the beneficial effects of FGF-2 supplementation are limited to early passages of adipocyte precursors, while sustained supplementation in later passages is associated with detrimental effects due to the decline in FGFR1 expression and subsequent reduction in STAT3 phosphorylation [121].In human adipocytes, FGF-2 and FGFR1 are downregulated as they differentiate into adipocytes.Adipocyte precursors expressing a dominant negative form of FGFR1 or treated with a specific inhibitor of FGFR1 signaling completely lose their ability to form lipid-containing adipocytes.Thus, FGF signaling plays a crucial role in both the expansion of progenitors and their subsequent differentiation [122].
Additional FGFs have been demonstrated to be either produced by or exert effects on adipocyte precursors, although the roles of specific FGFs in adipocyte precursor proliferation are limited.Fgf10 is highly expressed in WAT, particularly in APs [123].FGF10 acts on AP in WAT through autocrine/paracrine signaling, promoting cell proliferation via the activation of FGFR2b and the Ras/MAPK pathway [124].WAT development is greatly impaired in Fgf10 knockout mouse embryos, however, its roles at postnatal stages remain unclear as Fgf10 knockout mice die shortly after birth with impaired multi-organ formation [123].FGF6, a paracrine factor primarily expressed in fully differentiated adipocytes, stimulates the proliferation of PDGFRα+ adipocyte precursor cells through ERK signaling and is downregulated in mature adipocytes during obesity and aging [125].Furthermore, mice subjected to a high-fat diet, with persistent inguinal WAT-specific FGF6 blockade using a neutralizing antibody or Fgf6-null mice, display notable adipocyte hypertrophy, adipose fibrosis, inflammation, and impaired glucose tolerance that is coupled with an expedited deficiency in adipocyte precursor abundance [125].These results suggest that FGF6 plays a protective role in maintaining the adipocyte precursor pool to maintain metabolic health.

BMP Signaling and Adipogenic Precursor Commitment
Perhaps, among growth factors, none have been as extensively examined for their involvement in adipogenesis as the bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs).BMP2, BMP4, BMP7, BMP9, and others are associated with the direct control of ASCs and their commitment to adipocyte progenitors (APs).This regulatory influence can steer their differentiation toward white, beige, or brown adipocytes, depending on the specific BMP ligand or the context (Figure 1L) [126][127][128][129].

BMP2 directs adipogenic precursors towards a white adipocyte fate
Experiments with mouse cell lines have shown that supplementing exogenous BMP2 promotes adipogenesis in 3T3L1 APs and induces commitment to the adipocyte lineage in C3H10T1/2 MSCs [126,130].This response is orchestrated via SMAD1/5/8 signaling, resulting in increased expression of the adipogenic transcription factors PPARγ and C/EBPα [131,132].Human abdominal and gluteal adipose tissue, along with adipogenic precursors isolated from these tissues, exhibit BMP2 expression [133].In human abdominal adipocyte precursors, BMP2 signaling includes SMAD1/5/8 phosphorylation, leading to enhanced PPARγ expression and triacylglyceride accumulation [133].Intriguingly, multiple studies have revealed an association between a BMP2-linked polymorphism (rs979012) and an increased waist-to-hip ratio and BMI, underscoring the role of BMP signaling in adipose tissue physiology [133][134][135].

BMP4 induces a white or brown phenotype based on the cellular context
Previous research on BMP4 revealed its capacity to commit C3H10T1/2 MSCs to an adipocyte lineage, as indicated by an increased occurrence of adipocyte formation when exposed to inducers of adipogenic differentiation [126,127,136].Adipocytes in mice, featuring transgenic overexpression of BMP4 under the Fabp4 promoter, display browning of inguinal WAT, increased energy expenditure and protection against high-fat dietinduced obesity, coupled with enhanced insulin sensitivity [137].Conversely, mice lacking Bmp4 display hypertrophy of white adipocytes and heightened insulin resistance [137].
Intriguingly, the expression of BMP4 in human WAT shows a negative correlation with body mass index, indicating its potential role in promoting increased energy expenditure [137].
The role of BMP4 in determining a white or beige/brown phenotype is cell type-dependent.BMP4 induces MSCs to commit to APs, promoting beige adipogenesis.However, in mature adipocytes, BMP4 suppresses the beige phenotype and supports the development of a white phenotype [128].BMP4 is present in both APs and mature adipocytes, yet in WAT APs, the potential of BMP4 to stimulate beige adipogenesis might be inhibited by the expression of gremlin 1 (GREM1), an inhibitor of BMP4/7 [138,139].BMP4 expression is evident in brown preadipocytes, as well as other cells within the SVF, including MSCs and endothelial cells, with a gradual decrease observed during the final stages of brown adipocyte differentiation [140].In contrast, white adipocytes exhibit higher BMP4 expression in mature adipocytes compared to the SVF [141].Hence, it has been suggested that BMP4 signaling gradually diminishes from the stem cell niche to the mature adipocyte during the development of beige and brown adipocytes, possibly attributed to local diffusion and the synthesis of BMP4 antagonists [140].
The control of beige and brown adipogenesis by BMP4 derived from adipose tissue may also involve its impact on other cells present in the adipose tissue microenvironment.In a recent investigation, Fabp4-Bmp4 transgenic mice were shown to stimulate the proliferation of CD206+ M2 macrophages while inhibiting M1 macrophages, resulting in a substantial rise in M2 macrophage numbers [141].This phenomenon might explain the observed enhancement of WAT browning.Consistent with this notion, the transfer of BMP4induced M2 macrophages to subcutaneous WAT resulted in the upregulation of brown adipocyte markers, including PRDM16, peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-gamma coactivator 1 alpha (PGC1α), and UCP1, accompanied by an elevation in whole-body oxygen consumption [141].Therefore, the findings from earlier investigations indicating that BMP4 induces a browning effect in WAT, leading to heightened energy expenditure and improved metabolism, might be attributed, at least in part, to the regulatory role of BMP4 on macrophages (Figures 1J and 2E).

BMP7 is necessary for brown/beige adipocyte precursor commitment
Investigations using Bmp7 null mice have demonstrated the essential role of BMP7 in the development and differentiation of brown adipocyte precursors, leading to the formation of brown adipose tissue and preservation of its thermogenic program [129].Notably, administering BMP7 systemically to mice effectively counteracts obesity by enhancing energy expenditure and suppressing appetite [142].Genetic deletion of the type 1A BMP receptor (Bmpr1a) within the MYF5+ lineage, the embryonic precursor cells to brown adipose tissue [1], results in a deficiency of interscapular BAT and stimulates beige adipogenesis in WAT [143].This effect, mediated by heightened sympathetic nervous system input, indicates intercommunication between these two adipose depots and reinstates the overall thermogenic capacity mediated by thermogenic adipocytes, ensuring the preservation of normal body temperature and resistance to diet-induced obesity [143].Adipogenic precursors obtained from subcutaneous WAT exhibit synergistic induction toward a BAT-like phenotype when treated with BMP7 together with β3-adrenergic agonists.This implies a direct involvement of BMP signaling in promoting beige adipogenesis [144,145].BMP7 has also been utilized in the ex vivo generation of brown adipocytes from both human embryonic stem cells and iPSCs, highlighting its potential significance in the development of human BAT [146].
The signaling and transcriptional mechanisms underlying BMP regulation of adipogenesis are not fully understood.However, there is evidence suggesting that BMP7 facilitates brown and beige adipogenesis by regulating EBF2 and ZFP423 via SMAD-induced mechanisms [147].EBF2 serves as a transcription factor with selective expression in brown and beige adipocyte precursors, playing a regulatory role in the expression of target genes specific to brown adipose tissue, including Prdm16 [148][149][150].The transcriptional regulator ZFP423 acts as a corepressor of EBF2, playing a crucial role in preserving the identity of white adipocytes by suppressing Prdm16 [151].Upon activation of adipocyte precursors by BMP7, SMAD1/4 engages with ZFP423, leading to the disruption of the ZFP423-EBF2 protein complex.This interaction facilitates EBF2 to initiate the expression of target genes associated with brown adipogenesis, including Prdm16 [151].

BMP9 is a secreted hepatokine that initiates browning of WAT adipogenic precursors
BMP-9 is a hepatokine that regulates glucose homeostasis-related enzymes and injection of recombinant human BMP-9 successfully reduces blood glucose levels in diabetic mice [152].Furthermore, recombinant BMP9 promotes brown adipogenesis in human ASCs [153].Intraperitoneal administration of BMP9 in mice with high-fat diet-induced obesity results in significant browning of subcutaneous WAT, leading to reduced weight gain, smaller white adipocytes and decreased fasting blood glucose levels [153].Cold exposure in mice for 3 weeks increases hepatic BMP9 expression and plasma levels [154].Treatment of cell cultures with BMP9 facilitates the differentiation of subcutaneous WAT-derived adipogenic precursors into beige adipocytes.This is evidenced by elevated expression levels of markers associated with brown adipocytes and mitochondrial biogenesis, including increased UCP1 and PGC1α expression, respectively [154].In vivo administration of BMP9 triggers the expression of browning markers in WAT.In mice fed a high-fat diet, BMP9 administration protects against obesity and improves glucose tolerance [154].In conclusion, either pharmacological treatment with BMP9 or liver secretion of BMP9 induced by cold exposure can promote adipocyte browning, leading to a reduction in fat mass and amelioration of dysregulated blood glucose levels in high-fat diet-induced obese mice.

Regulation of ASC Pluripotency and Self-renewal
Ensuring the continual self-renewal and multipotency potential within the ASC pool is a crucial element for the overall regulation and equilibrium of adipose tissue homeostasis.This dynamic equilibrium is essential for the proper functioning of adipose tissue, influencing aspects such as adipocyte turnover, tissue repair, and responsiveness to physiological demands [155].OCT4, SOX2, and NANOG are transcription factors that inhibit genes associated with differentiation, preserving pluripotency [156,157].Through physical interactions, they modulate each other's expression, thereby regulating target genes crucial for self-renewal and pluripotency [156,157].While OCT4, NANOG, and SOX2 are expressed at lower levels in ASCs compared to embryonic stem cells, several studies have consistently shown that these genes are linked to heightened self-renewal and multipotency within the ASC population (Figure 1L) [30,158,159].Like CD34, a widely recognized marker for ASCs that undergoes rapid downregulation during ex vivo expansion, the levels of OCT4, NANOG, and SOX2 also diminish rapidly in cell culture [160].This rapid decrease in expression may explain previous controversy surrounding the expression of these markers in ASCs observed in earlier studies.In support of this, isolation techniques that enhance the purity of primary CD34+ ASCs lead to a 2-3 fold increase in the expression of OCT4, NANOG, and SOX2 [161].During replicative senescence associated with extended ex vivo expansion of ASCs, heightened levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) lead to diminished proliferation, pluripotency, and expression of OCT4, NANOG, and SOX2 [162].This senescent state is concomitant with ROS-mediated reduction of the transcription factor c-MAF, known for its direct binding to and regulation of OCT4, NANOG, and SOX2 expression [162].Lastly, elements that enhance pluripotency in mouse embryonic stem cells, such as the addition of leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF) or the overexpression of the mir-302 cluster, also contribute to the capacity of ASCs to sustain the expression of pluripotency genes [160].
Functional investigations have revealed the involvement of pluripotency genes in governing ASC functionality.Elevated OCT4 expression leads to the demethylation of regulatory regions associated with stemness genes, including OCT4, NANOG, and SOX2, thereby enhancing ASC proliferation and multipotency [163].The suppression of NANOG in ASCs induces a reduction in the expression of OCT4 and SOX2 genes, leading to decreased proliferation attributed to cell cycle arrest in G0/G1 [164].Within MSCs derived from bone marrow, OCT4 and NANOG exhibit binding activity to the promoter region of DNA methyltransferase 1 (DNMT1) [165].This interaction plays a crucial role in suppressing genes associated with differentiation by maintaining methylation levels during DNA replication.Consistent with this, the inhibition of NANOG in ASCs results in a decline in pluripotency and differentiation capacity through the downregulation of DNMT1 [166][167][168].
The precise regulation of Nanog and Oct4 expression in ASCs might be partially influenced by programmed cell death 4 (Pdcd4), a protein translation suppressor linked to diet-induced obesity, WAT inflammation and insulin resistance [155,169].Pdcd4 ablation in mice correlates with elevated levels of Oct4 and Nanog, leading to heightened stemness and proliferation of ASCs through increased AKT activation and upregulation of cyclinD1 [155].Remarkably, Pdcd4 ablation also promotes the transition from white to beige adipocytes, resulting in augmented energy expenditure and resistance to obesity on a high-fat diet [155].These findings imply that enhanced stemness of ASCs could play a beneficial role in preventing obesity and metabolic syndrome.
Genes specifically associated with specific functions related to adipose tissue might also govern the expression of pluripotency genes in ASCs.As the proliferation and differentiation potential of ASCs decline with successive passages in culture, there is a simultaneous decrease in PPARγ and thyroid hormone receptor (TRβ), concomitant with the loss of OCT4 [170].Administering PPARγ agonists to ASCs enhances OCT4 promoter activity, expression, and rejuvenates differentiation potential as ASCs undergo aging in culture [170].Throughout the culture of ASCs, the observed decline in proliferative potential and stemness is additionally linked to an age-related reduction in proteasome complex and peptidase activities [171].In particular, the activation of the proteasome is correlated with reduced levels of ROS, elongated telomeres, and elevated expression of OCT4, NANOG, and SOX2, simultaneously leading to an augmentation in stemness [171].Conversely, the silencing of OCT4 or NANOG leads to a notable decrease in proteasomal activity, attributed to the diminished association of OCT4 with β2 and β5 proteasomal subunit promoters, indicating that pluripotency genes might, in part, govern stemness through modulation of proteostasis [171].Overall, the intricate interplay between pluripotency genes and various factors highlights the complexity of ASC regulation, offering insights into potential strategies for manipulating their cellular properties.

Disease
When exposed to a high-fat diet, adipocyte precursors contribute to the onset of adipocyte hyperplasia.However, the extent of new adipocyte formation varies among distinct adipose tissue depots [172].In mice, the initiation of adipogenesis in the visceral WAT depot occurs significantly before adipocyte hypertrophy that occurs during the development of diet-induced obesity [65].Likewise, the enlargement of human visceral WAT may rely on a surge in adipocyte proliferation during the initiation of obesity [173].Notably, both in humans and mice, fully developed obesity is linked to a decline in adipocyte precursors and a diminished capacity for their differentiation, which can result in adipocyte hypertrophy, adipose dysfunction, and the onset of metabolic syndrome [174,175].Hence, during periods of energy excess and the onset of diabetes, adipocyte precursors exhibit efficient proliferation and differentiation into adipocytes, yet face impairment in later stages, potentially contributing to adipocyte hypertrophy and the exacerbation of metabolic abnormalities [30].Moreover, in individuals with obesity, a reduction in ASC activity may constrain their overall multipotent and regenerative capacity, which are critical factors for patients who could potentially benefit from autologous transplantation.
In contrast to lean individuals, ASCs extracted from subcutaneous and visceral WAT in obese patients exhibit decreased cell proliferation, premature senescence, and a decline in both angiogenic potential and the ability for multilineage differentiation [91,174,[176][177][178]. ASCs in obese patients demonstrate a compromised capacity to release proangiogenic factors such as VEGF, HGF, FGF, and PDGF.This impairment can hinder angiogenesis, induce hypoxia, and lead to cellular stress, ultimately contributing to adipocyte death [30,[132][133][134][135].In obese individuals, the decline in ASC multipotency is associated with an upregulation of genes related to inflammation and a concurrent downregulation of genes associated with embryonic development and multilineage differentiation, including TBX15, HOXC10, and α-SMA, potentially contributing to a compromised tissue repair capacity [91,177].
ASCs have been observed to exhibit robust immunosuppressive activity, playing a crucial role in the regulation of inflammation and immunopathologic responses.Additionally, this characteristic is significant for the development and application of immunomodulation therapies and allogeneic stem cell treatments [179,180].ASCs obtained from obese and type 2 diabetic individuals exhibit diminished immunosuppressive functions, such as suppressing immune cell proliferation and polarizing macrophages towards the M2 phenotype, in contrast to those derived from lean individuals (Figure 2F) [181].ASCs from obese individuals exhibit up-regulation of inflammatory genes such as IL-1β, IL-8, and monocyte chemoattractant protein 1 (MCP1), previously associated with elevated BMI and linked to cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes risk [91].The increased expression of these cytokines, coupled with elevated levels of tumor necrosis factor-α (TNFα) and IL-6 in ASCs, may potentially contribute to the initiation or exacerbation of adipose tissue inflammation and foster insulin resistance by attracting and directing macrophages towards the M1 subtype (Figure 2F) [30,[182][183][184][185].
Genes associated with stemness exhibit dysregulation in obesity and type 2 diabetes, with ASCs from subcutaneous WAT of obese patients displaying decreased expression of OCT4, SAL4, SOX15, and KLF4, while ASCs from omental WAT show increased expression [186].In a separate investigation, heightened expression of OCT4 and NANOG was noted in ASCs obtained from both subcutaneous and visceral WAT in diabetic individuals compared to those without diabetes [187].Additional markers of stemness, such as reduced viability of ASCs in cell culture, diminished telomerase activity, and shortened telomere length, provide further evidence of the disrupted self-renewal capacity in ASCs derived from individuals with obesity [188].Concerning telomerase activity, the selective disruption of either Pdgfrα + or Pdgfrβ+ adipocyte progenitor lineages in telomerase reverse transcriptase gene knockout mice results in premature telomere shortening, adipocyte progenitor senescence, and subsequent adverse metabolic effects.These effects include adipocyte hypertrophy, inflammation, and fibrosis in adipose tissue, as well as systemic insulin resistance, further exacerbated by a high-fat diet [189].This information suggests that excessive nutrient intake can induce senescence in adipose progenitor cells, establishing a mechanistic connection between aging, obesity, and diabetes.
In obese individuals, inflammatory cytokines like IL-6 or TNFα are known to shorten cilia in ASCs, impairing their ability to respond adequately to stimuli [190].The use of an inhibitor targeting Aurora A, a kinase involved in cilia disassembly, has been shown to reverse this phenotype, restoring cilia length and function in obese ASCs [191].Remarkably, this reversal is linked to an upregulation of self-renewal and stemness genes, suggesting a potential approach to address obesity-related disorders [191].
Overall, disturbances in gene networks associated with stemness, inflammation, multilineage potential, and ASC trafficking and homing contribute to ASC dysfunction [91].Dysfunctional ASCs, by disrupting adipose tissue remodeling, promoting inflammation, and inducing hypoxia, may play a role in the development of obesity and related diseases [30,192].Supporting this notion, supplementing obese mice with ASCs from lean counterparts has been found to reduce adipose inflammation, enhance insulin action, and restore metabolic balance [175].Therefore, ensuring effective proliferation, renewal, and differentiation of ASCs is crucial for proper adipose tissue function, and the restoration of ASCs could be a promising strategy in combating obesity-related diseases [30,155].

Lifestyle Interventions in Adipose Tissue Remodeling
Adipose tissue exhibits remarkable adaptability in response to changes in energy demand.Exercise plays a pivotal role in modulating the endocrine profile of adipose tissues, regulating mitochondrial activity, and enhancing glucose uptake [193].The enlargement and reduced efficiency of adipocytes seen in obesity are often linked to increased lipogenesis and impaired angiogenesis.It's widely acknowledged that exercise upregulates Mdm2 expression, promoting angiogenesis, stimulating lipolysis, and suppressing lipogenic gene expression in adipose tissue [194][195][196].These mechanisms, which counteract hypoxia and hypertrophic adipocyte development, likely contribute to the promotion of smaller, metabolically healthier adipocytes through exercise.
Adipose tissue harbors functionally distinct populations of APs identified by CD34 and CD9 as pro-adipogenic (CD34 low and CD9 low ) and pro-fibrotic (CD34 high and CD9 high ] [197][198][199][200]. Recent research suggests intense exercise reduces pro-fibrotic CD34 high adipocyte precursors in human abdominal subcutaneous fat without affecting CD34 low APs in the same individuals, indicating exercise's potential to favorably modulate the adipocyte precursor pool [201].Animal studies have shown that exercise training increases vascular density in the adipose tissue of obese rats compared to sedentary counterparts [202].Similarly, clinical investigations involving individuals with insulin resistance demonstrate that both sprint interval training and moderate-intensity continuous training elevate vascular density in subcutaneous adipose tissue [203].Exercise's immunomodulatory effects may also mitigate obesity-induced inflammation in adipose tissue by reducing inflammatory macrophages and promoting an anti-inflammatory M2 macrophage phenotype [202,204,205].Furthermore, exercise decreases the number of CD8 + T cells and macrophage infiltration in obesityrelated adipose tissue, while enhancing the secretion of anti-inflammatory cytokines IL6 and IL10 and shifting macrophage phenotype from M1 to M2 in the subcutaneous fat of high-fat diet mice, resulting in improved insulin sensitivity [205].
In rodents, calorie restriction decreases fat mass, delays age-related diseases like type 2 diabetes, and extends lifespan [206].Similarly, in obese individuals, calorie restriction, weight loss, and exercise enhance insulin sensitivity [207].Studies by Fabbiano et al. indicate that calorie restriction reduces total fat mass while promoting the browning of white adipose tissue, accompanied by increased eosinophils, M2 macrophages, and type 2 cytokine signaling [208].Calorie restriction stimulates mitochondrial biogenesis in various tissues, including skeletal muscle, liver, heart, and WAT, with SREBP-1c mediating mitochondrial biogenesis specifically in WAT [209][210][211].The correlation between calorie restriction and browning markers in humans remains ambiguous, as studies have demonstrated that observed improvements in body fat and insulin resistance appear to be unrelated to browning [212].

Conclusions and Future Perspectives
Understanding the adipose tissue stem cell niche has been hindered by challenges in identifying specific markers for distinct cell subpopulations, the absence of optimal cell culture conditions maintaining cells in their native state, and a lack of in vivo models for monitoring cells within the native niche.Recent developments in 3D culture techniques and the discovery of new adipogenic growth factors offer potential solutions, allowing for the preservation and more accurate representation of the native niche ex vivo.This is particularly crucial when studying the physiological abnormalities of adipogenic precursors from obese patients, as culture conditions may inaccurately reflect the native niche, leading to incorrect assumptions about their role in disease progression.Supporting this, optimized 3D culture conditions that maintain the niche environment have already demonstrated improved clinical effects [213].
Earlier research has proposed that various cell types within the niche (such as endothelial, hematopoietic, mural, and fibroblastic cells) have the potential to serve as adipocyte precursors in vitro.However, lineage tracing studies in mice are now providing insights into the key populations contributing to mature adipocytes during normal metabolic homeostasis, weight gain, and WAT browning.Specifically, a fibroblast stem cell population, identified by PDGFRα and the mural cell marker PDGFRβ, seems to play a significant role in the formation of the majority of mature adipocytes in adult mice [82].Advances in singlecell RNA sequencing and the identification of non-cell surface markers for tracking and purifying adipogenic precursors may enable a more precise categorization of these cells into an ordered hierarchy of adipogenic commitment and potential.
ASCs and progenitors obtained from subcutaneous and visceral adipose tissues of obese individuals exhibit diminished cell proliferation, premature senescence, and a decline in angiogenic potential, as well as the capacity for multilineage differentiation [91,[174][175][176][177][178].Consequently, in the later stages of obesity, the impaired function of ASCs and adipocyte progenitors may contribute to adipocyte hypertrophy linked to excessive caloric intake and insulin resistance.Additionally, ASCs derived from obese and type 2 diabetes patients exhibit reduced immunosuppressive activity, including the inhibition of immune cell proliferation and the ability to polarize macrophages toward the M2 phenotype [181].Inflammatory cytokines linked to cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes risk are also upregulated in ASCs [91].Collectively, the restoration of ASCs through transplantation emerges as a potentially effective strategy to address complications associated with obesity, as demonstrated in mouse studies [175].
Understanding the molecular mechanisms governing the self-renewal and differentiation of ASCs and their downstream progenitors holds promise for the development of innovative therapies to address obesity-related disorders.For instance, exploring the mechanisms linked to BMP7-induced differentiation of beige/brown adipocytes may offer insights into developing therapies that enhance thermogenesis and provide protection against metabolic syndrome.There is a growing awareness of the significant impact macrophages have on both the renewal and differentiation potential of adipogenic precursors, with M2 macrophage subsets playing a role in maintaining a healthy balance between renewal and differentiation [111].Identifying factors associated with polarization toward the M2 phenotype (such as BMP4/IL-4) or factors from these cells that directly promote the generation of beige adipocytes from adipocyte precursors may open avenues for developing novel therapies for weight loss [109,110].
Creating conditions conducive to the functional co-culture of various cell types within the adipose precursor niche is increasingly crucial for advancing our understanding of how these cells interact and influence adipogenesis during normal, insulin-resistant and inflammatory states.The successful establishment of co-culture methods involving different subpopulations of ASCs, progenitors, macrophages, endothelial cells, neurons, mural cells, fibroblasts, and other cell types is paramount.For instance, attempts to coculture sympathetic neurons with ASCs for studying lipolysis and adipose tissue browning have faced challenges, potentially attributed to the secretion of factors in co-culture that hinder differentiation when the cells are isolated outside the native adipose tissue niche [214].Moreover, the research community is actively exploring the therapeutic potential of ASCs across various diseases and regenerative applications, encompassing soft tissue defect reconstruction, wound healing, skin restoration, skeletal muscle/bone reconstruction, liver regeneration and cardiac repair [215].Future identification of new regulatory factors governing the adipocyte precursor niche will contribute to determining optimal culturing methods for ASCs.This is not only crucial for advancing the study of metabolic diseases, but also for harnessing the potential of these cells in the field of regenerative medicine.(A) Adipose tissue consists of clusters of adipocytes arranged in lobules, which are separated from each other by ECM that forms the septa (B).In addition to the septa lining the outside of the lobule, the internal stroma also contains a distinct ECM compartment (C).(D) ECM within the stroma of the lobule contains CD34+/MSCA1+/CD271-APs that are highly adipogenic and positioned between adipocytes or adjacent to the vasculature.(E) ECM within the septa contains CD34+/MSCA1-/CD271+ myofibroblasts that may aid in formation of the fibrous septa and contribute to fibrosis during obesity.(F) PDGFRβ+ mural cells located in the vessel walls may harbor adipogenic activity, but recent data contradicts this and suggests PDGFRα+/β+ APs (G) located within the vessel wall adventitia contribute to the majority of adipocytes found in white, beige and brown adipocytes (H).(I) CD206+ M2 macrophages play a role in maintenance of APs through secretion of anti-adipogenic TGFβ1, which prevents exhaustion of the AP pool by limiting excessive proliferation and premature senescence.(J) IL-4 and BMP4 represent two potential factors that may decrease the proportion of M1 macrophages in adipose tissue in favor of anti-inflammatory M2 macrophages, which play a role in adipose tissue browning, protection from high-fat diet-induced obesity and improved metabolism.(K) FSP1+ fibroblasts found in the loose connective tissue outside the vessel wall rely on WNT signaling for proper function and lack adipogenic potential (red X).They contribute to the renewal and differentiation potential of APs through the secretion of PDGF-BB and remodeling of the ECM.(L) CD34+/CD24+ ASCs express markers of pluripotency (OCT4, NANOG and SOX2) and undergo FGF2 mediated self-renewal.BMP ligands can induce multipotent ASCs to form committed APs (A) Eosinophils secrete IL-4 and IL-13 that polarize macrophages toward an M2 fate, potentially contributing to browning and the formation of beige adipocytes through catecholamine secretion (B).(C) Secretion of IL-4 from eosinophils and potentially M2 macrophages may directly impact adipogenic precursors to enhance their capacity to undergo beige adipogenesis.(D) TGFβ1 expressed by CD206+ M2 macrophages hinders the proliferation of PDGFRα+ adipogenic precursors to prevent premature senescence and precursor cell exhaustion.(E) BMP4 derived from adipogenic precursors stimulates the proliferation of CD206+ M2 macrophages while inhibiting M1 macrophages, resulting in a substantial rise in M2 macrophage numbers that may lead to increased browning of WAT.(F) ASCs from obese and type 2 diabetic individuals exhibit up-regulation of inflammatory genes that may contribute to adipose tissue inflammation and insulin resistance by attracting and directing macrophages towards the M1 subtype.

Figure 1 :
Figure 1: Structure and interplay within the adipose tissue microenvironment.